search

vmarc / knooppuntnet

Route planner and quality assurance for walking and cycling networks in OpenStreetMap.
MIT License
31 stars 6 forks source link

Analyse - Guidepost without name create an "issue/fact" in analysis tool #285

Open Binnette opened 1 year ago

Binnette commented 1 year ago

Hi, in France we have a lot of guidepost without name: photo-5787254563919739955-y.jpg

It seems that adding this kind of guidepost to a hiking node network relation cause an "issue/fact". Can you please address this kind of guidepost to prevent creating a fact in your analysis tool? Those guideposts without name have the tag "noname=yes". So maybe you can create a rule in your analysis tool to disable analyse when a guidepost have this tag?

Example of guidepost with name: https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/1587011575 Example of guidepost without name: https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/8807102300

Have a nice day

vmarc commented 1 year ago

@Binnette thanks for asking this question, and also thanks for your translations!!! The results of your work should be visible online since the new release yesterday.

Currently, nodes in a route relation that are tagged with "tourism=information" and "information=guidepost" (or "information=map", or "information=board") are already ignored during the node network analysis. Both your example nodes should not cause any issue.

Close to your first example guidepost is the actual node network node, part of route Champ Fila - Odysée.

The second example guidepost does not seem to be part of any node network route.

Do you still see a need for knooppuntnet to look at tag "noname=yes"?