Drag and Drop interaction occurs with only `CTRL+C`

polarathene commented 2 years ago

Describe the bug

It is unexpected that files, especially large ones referenced in a host or guest clipboard would be transferred implicitly when transitioning between the host or guest (only requires mouse movement across the guest windows bounds to trigger).

The VMPlayer settings UI does not provide an option to manage the Copy/Paste and Drag'n'Drop support. I did come across the following VMX config lines that do:

isolation.tools.copy.disable = "TRUE"
isolation.tools.paste.disable = "TRUE"
isolation.tools.SetGUIOptions.enable = "TRUE"

The last line does not make any difference, GUI settings does not provide any additional options.
Disabling support for Copy/Paste does prevent the issue of unexpectedly copying over files (on Linux host I was able to cancel this operation, when I tried on a Windows 10 host earlier in the year I recall not being able to cancel the transfer, I have not yet verified if that issue remains). The problem this causes is it fully disables being able to leverage convenient copy/paste for text between guest/host.
Disabling DnD specifically with isolation.tools.dnd.disable = "TRUE" disables this feature (via mouse drag), but CTRL+C will continue to copy large files in clipboard to the ~/.config/vmware/drag_and_drop/ folder.

Reproduction steps

1. Start VM guest.
2. Copy file from VM guest, or host and switch to the other.
3. Implicit file transfer begins.

Expected behavior

CTRL+C should not trigger an implicit file transfer/copy. This is separate from the Drag and Drop feature that is explicit. If users desire this implicit behaviour (which requires 2x storage due to copy that stays inside the cache), it should be possible to opt-out (or preferably be opt-in by default).

Additional context

The official docs VMWare Workstation 16 (last updated May 2019) only describe a GUI method to perform the equivalent VMX config changes, but the VMPlayer (at least on Linux host) does not provide such "Guest Isolation" settings and this appears to be the case as far back as 2014 (version 6.0).

I discovered the VMX config for disabling copy/paste from unofficial sources online. And after considering that DnD feature is probably separate, I found a 2007 VMware community support thread discussing it's equivalent config line. It's unclear if this is better documented somewhere by VMware officially...

I have required VMX editing for other features such as setting EFI firmware or Boot device order. It is unclear why GUI support is lacking or better official documentation for equivalent VMX config file settings. I am interested in becoming a customer still, but features need to work correctly first.

Environment

I could additionally verify with the following if desired:

I have access to a Fedora 36 host and guest install.
I recall having this same problem on a Windows 10 host to a linux guest earlier in the year as well. It was very irritating during evaluation of VMware software.

Host:

OS: Manjaro (Arch Linux), fully updated.
Kernel: 5.17.6-1-MANJARO (with DKMS for VMware kernel modules)
vmware-worksation v16.2.3 (AUR package)
XFS filesystem, NVIDIA 1070 GPU (510.68.02 driver), X11 session (xorg 21.1.3), KDE Plasma 5.24 desktop.
VMware Workstation Player: 16.2.3

Guest:

OS: EndeavorOS (Arch Linux), fully updated.
Kernel: 5.17.5-arch1-1
XFS filesystem, 3D Accel enabled (2.20.0.0 vmwgfx driver, Mesa 22.0.3), X11 session (xorg 21.1.3), KDE Plasma 5.24 desktop.
open-vm-tools: 12.0.0

If the desktop & app allow a selected file icon to be transferred to the desktop clipboard with Ctrl+C, than it will also be available in the hosted products transfer clipboard. I do not have access to an Arch Linux VM, but on Fedora 35, I can copy/paste a file in the file manager (Nautilus) panes using Ctrl-C & Ctrl-V. And it is available to paste in an appropriate app on the host desktop.

If as a personal choice you wish to suppress file copy / paste, then try this.

If I add the following lines to the VM's .vmx configuration file,

isolation.tools.copy.disable = "FALSE" isolation.tools.paste.disable = "FALSE" isolation.tools.copyPaste.File.disable = "TRUE"

there is no copy / paste of the file to the Windows host desktop.

Please let us know if the above settings provides the behavior you desire. And if there is any additional help needed, just ask.

Since copy/paste defaults are as expected, clearing the "bug" label.

polarathene commented 2 years ago

If the desktop & app allow a selected file icon to be transferred to the desktop clipboard with Ctrl+C, than it will also be available in the hosted products transfer clipboard.

Uhhh.. sure, but when I do that on the host no actual copy/transfer occurs. When VMPlayer is active though, switching to the guest would initiate an implicit transfer which is not expected or desired personally. Likewise, within the guest if switching to another window on the host.

isolation.tools.copyPaste.File.disable

There's exactly 3 results for this on Google (all VMware forum support threads) :sweat_smile:

Is any of this documented somewhere? I understand there's meant to be a settings UI for it, but it's not present in VMPlayer 16.2.3 on linux for some reason.

That did do the trick though, thanks!

on Fedora 35, I can copy/paste a file in the file manager (Nautilus) panes using Ctrl-C & Ctrl-V. And it is available to paste in an appropriate app on the host desktop.

For me on Arch and Fedora hosts with an Arch guest, this resulted in an implicit transfer, it'd be totally fine if the functionality resulted in a transfer when you explicitly paste to the host or guest from the other. Perhaps that's the intended experience.

I had a similar problem on a Windows 10 host earlier in the year where I don't think I could cancel the transfer to Arch guest.
While with the Arch host the transfer to Arch guest effectively loops on repeat (technically requires another click into the guest window).
On a Fedora host the transfer to an Arch guest still happens but does not loop.

It's possible that there is something not compatible with Arch or KDE, I'll need to test with a Fedora Gnome guest to confirm, then isolate if it's Arch or KDE related. Everything else seems to be at parity though between Arch and Fedora.

SonyaWAlston commented 5 months ago

try: echo 'isolation.tools.copyPaste.File.disable = "TRUE"' >> $HOME/.vmware/config

vmware / open-vm-tools