search

voc / srtrelay

SRT relay server for distributing media streams to multiple clients.
MIT License
134 stars 37 forks source link

Adapt StreamID scheme to SRT standards #3

Closed iSchluff closed 1 year ago

iSchluff commented 3 years ago

https://github.com/Haivision/srt/blob/master/docs/AccessControl.md

ravenium commented 3 years ago

I was playing with a media server that follows this spec https://github.com/ossrs/srs , and honestly it felt quite cumbersome for streaming compared to RTMP's simple app/streamid pair. Also, bash really doesn't like shebangs when using ffmpeg on the command line, but that might be an outlier.

That said, it's not the end of the world and would be more spec compliant than SLS. Plus, This might be the best way to implement SRT crypto/passphrase checking for streams?

Just a .02.

iSchluff commented 3 years ago

At the moment it's not really relevant anyway because all implementers of streamid I know of so far (ffmpeg and obs) just give you a text field. It would be interesting to see whether broadcast devices will allow setting a streamid. Afaik at the moment they mostly don't.

If more applications follow the official scheme it would be nice to adopt it as well.

I think for crypto/passphrase we are dependent on https://github.com/Haivision/srtgo/issues/12 but I haven't tried it at all yet.

fu5ha commented 2 years ago

Small update here, most broadcast devices (my reference point here being various cheap standalone video encoder boxes on the market) allow setting the streamid field as just a text box as specified above and ultimately work quite well with the current scheme.

p10tyr commented 1 year ago

This is non issue.. I actually prefer this because like LiveU Solo doesn't support stream ID -- so if I had multiple streams incoming... I would need multiple docker images. So this way, for example - I can stream from Larix on a mobile phone to another "channel" and have it available for mixing, all within one solution- Keep It Simple!

This actually solves the problem nicely and is very explicit, publish, play - it just work

Also thank you very much for this.. the multiple subscription is what I was looking for- super light weight freaking awesome!

iSchluff commented 1 year ago

will close this as manufacturers will probably never support it anyway

p10tyr commented 1 year ago

LiveU - just put in the publish/streamname in the stream id.. works fine. If there is no input for that then just add it your self on the end of the url streamid=publish/streamname