search

voxpupuli / puppet-network

Types and providers to manage network interfaces
https://forge.puppet.com/puppet/network
Apache License 2.0
66 stars 107 forks source link

Are there any plans to support `netplan` with Ubuntu 18? #239

Open mdwheele opened 6 years ago

mdwheele commented 6 years ago

Related: https://wiki.ubuntu.com/Netplan, https://wiki.ubuntu.com/MigratingToNetplan

If there is a better place for this type of question, let me know and I can close.

Netplan is an abstraction over NetworkManager / networkd. It uses YAML configuration files to specify supported backends and renders configs. It currently is released on Ubuntu 17.10 and will ship with Ubuntu 18.04 LTS.

Where does this module fit in that landscape? Would the advice be to disable management abstractions like Netplan and rely on the module? Or would expanding scope of this module to manage Netplan, itself (for Ubuntu systems) be a reasonable approach?

Mostly interested in discussion; no specific issue to report.

bastelfreak commented 6 years ago

Hi @mdwheele, thanks for bringing this up. I am not sure if this module is the right place for netplan, probably not. Maybe it needs its own module, which uses puppet-network as a dependency (depending on the type of backend)? For networkd support you maybe want to check out https://github.com/camptocamp/puppet-systemd.

amuckart commented 3 years ago

Hi @mdwheele, thanks for bringing this up. I am not sure if this module is the right place for netplan, probably not.

It seems strange to me to have a module called 'network' that can't manage the default network configuration system of a major distribution. Should this perhaps be renamed to 'ifupdown' instead?