search

w3c-ccg / did-wg-charter

An EXPERIMENTAL charter for the W3C Decentralized Identifier Working Group
https://w3c-ccg.github.io/did-wg-charter/
Other
10 stars 4 forks source link

Clarify statement around VCWG coordination re Normalization and Signatures #12

Closed nadalin closed 5 years ago

nadalin commented 5 years ago

"Verifiable Claims Working Group Coordination on named graph indexing and other concerns regarding support for normalization and digital signatures"

Remove or reword as there is no normalization or signatures in VC WG, there should be no dependencies on VC for DID

kimdhamilton commented 5 years ago

Key concern is not requiring JSON-LD processor for JSON-only syntaxes

nadalin commented 5 years ago

@kimdhamilton and not pulling in unfinished/non-started standards like the LD-Signature and LD-C14N specs

kimdhamilton commented 5 years ago

What about something like this?

"Coordination on named graph indexing and other concerns in support of syntaxes/proof mechanisms requiring canonicalization, in a manner that does not impose burden (in the form of standards or libraries) if otherwise not required."

(Sorry that it's awkward, I'm still learning)

@burnburn @msporny @nadalin

nadalin commented 5 years ago

@kimdhamilton I can't parse that to tell if proof mechanisms are in or out of scope as it sounds like they are as long as you don't burden them with C14N, is that right?

nadalin commented 5 years ago

"Coordination on named graph indexing and other concerns regarding support for normalization and digital signatures." the VCWG is not working on normalizations and signatures as that is out of scope for that WG I was told. So I would leave it at "Coordination on named graph indexing."

msporny commented 5 years ago

The group discussed this on the 2019-06-27 call and agreed that we should remove the language, primarily because the Verifiable Claims Working Group will not exist by the time the DID WG starts. The group also identified that we should have more groups listed in this section and will raise another issue to ensure that we have more groups listed so that it is easier to understand where this work fits in relation to other work in this area.

msporny commented 5 years ago

Removed reference to W3C Verifiable Claims WG in this commit: https://github.com/w3c-ccg/did-wg-charter/commit/0b05193fdbfc81929558652ab8120c4c0d255faa

msporny commented 5 years ago

New issue raised for making coordination section better: https://github.com/w3c-ccg/did-wg-charter/issues/44

msporny commented 5 years ago

We discussed this on the 2019-06-27 call, made the changes above, and the group agreed that we have addressed this issue. Closing.