search

w3c-social / social-ucr

Social Web Use Cases and Requirements
https://w3c-social.github.io/social-ucr
5 stars 0 forks source link

Profile Management #1

Open elf-pavlik opened 9 years ago

elf-pavlik commented 9 years ago

original: https://www.w3.org/wiki/Socialwg/Social_API/User_stories#User_profile_management proposed alternative: by @evanp https://www.w3.org/wiki/Socialwg/Social_API/More_user_stories#User_profile_management_V2 by @dissolve

elf-pavlik commented 9 years ago

@tantek does proposed by @dissolve alternative version takes care of your objections? https://www.w3.org/wiki/Socialwg/Social_API/More_user_stories#User_profile_management_V2

tantek commented 9 years ago

This revised version takes care of the questions / objections I originally noted, however since our telcon discussion 2015-03-31, it became clear that we don't actually need any kind of profile management in v1 of an API, thus I'd -1 the whole user story with the explanation, can postpone from v1, open to reconsideration for a v2 API.

melvincarvalho commented 9 years ago

-1 to V2

+1 to the original user story

The original user story got 13 +1s 1 +0

We've already implemented V1 in SoLiD and demoed it live at the F2F

"Twitter doesnt do X" should not be a deal breaker for our user stories.

dissolve commented 9 years ago

@melvincarvalho, read @tantek's previous post on this thread.

Also. API V1 is meant to be a minimum set of needed functionality to get an API out which means ideally focusing on cross section of all sites.

As stated several times before the # of +1 votes does not matter. The idea is to get full consensus, not majority rule.

melvincarvalho commented 9 years ago

Well what is clear is that there was a VERY strong consensus for this user story.

We are unclear what v1 and v2 are, elf has raised this on IRC.

The consistent message is that implementations count. This user story is now implemented and demoed.

Also I beleive this is one of the ONLY user stories actually implemented and demonstrated live. So together with the very strong initial consensus, I think that is an important data point.