In the items listed in Thorough Review, we mention all of the wide review aspects. I wonder if we should add something around "technically sound" in it.
The core of a TAG design review is around ensuring us not shipping bad technical solutions, and the other aspects don't capture that well (e.g. API soundness, ergonomics, consistency/interoperability with other APIs).
cwilso
commented
2 days ago
In the items listed in Thorough Review, we mention all of the wide review aspects. I wonder if we should add something around "technically sound" in it.
The core of a TAG design review is around ensuring us not shipping bad technical solutions, and the other aspects don't capture that well (e.g. API soundness, ergonomics, consistency/interoperability with other APIs).
CC: @wareid @torgo @plinss