search

w3c / adapt

Semantics to describe user personalization preferences.
https://w3c.github.io/adapt/
Other
51 stars 27 forks source link

Content Module 1: destination vs. rel attribute #172

Closed dauwhe closed 3 years ago

dauwhe commented 3 years ago

There seems to be some overlap between the destination attribute and the existing rel attribute. What would be the difference between data-destination="help" and rel="help"? Would authors be encouraged to use both?

johnfoliot commented 3 years ago

Thank you for your question/feedback.

The difference between the @rel attribute values and @destination attribute values only has one apparent overlap: Help.

Our use cases currently see applying the value of help to both the @destination AND @action attributes (different outcomes), and we do not believe that having this value will introduce any conflicts or collisions with @rel usage. Conversely, removing the help value from @destination would leave the appearance of a hole in our specification.

Additionally, we envision feature-specific helper-applications that individual users would deploy to take advantage of this additional semantic markup, and we believe sticking with a common authoring pattern would be beneficial to those anticipated tools (i.e. support ALL of our spec, and not need to research other specs to deliver the required functionality). This would not be the first time that a content author can construct the same semantic outcome using more than one technique, although specific to our use cases we would (of course) recommend the @destination="help" author pattern to address the user need.