w3c / automotive

W3C Automotive Working Group Specifications
Other
145 stars 68 forks source link

Potential support of structs in VSS #461

Closed erikbosch closed 1 year ago

erikbosch commented 1 year ago

For information, there are discussions in VSS to support structs. It could be an idea to discuss implications/expectations on VISS, so that we agree on how it might affect the standard and reference implementation. Potential topics:

References:

UlfBj commented 1 year ago

It is to my knowledge not clear, or discussed, how a struct should be represented in a payload. I am not in favor of the paradigm to define structs using nodes in the tree. This will e. g. significantly increase the complexity of a tree parser. Applying the filter model to struct data would add another dimension of complexity, as I see it. My current view is that if this is to be supported, it will have to be in a coming version of VISS, not v2.

tguild commented 1 year ago

discussed on 2023-04-04 call, as struct is moving forward in VSS we should address here as well. Ulf to draft a solution to accommodate

UlfBj commented 1 year ago

Fixed in PR480