w3c / charter-webperf

Web Performance Group charter
https://w3c.github.io/charter-webperf/
27 stars 11 forks source link

Adding new specifications to charter #34

Closed igrigorik closed 7 years ago

igrigorik commented 7 years ago

As Discussed on WG call on 02/08/17, adding to charter:

igrigorik commented 7 years ago

/cc @plehegar @toddreifsteck @yoavweiss @spanicker

yoavweiss commented 7 years ago

LGTM! Regarding Server Timing, I'm hoping to start work on use-cases doc/explainer and spec soon

plehegar commented 7 years ago

The "out of scope" section includes "methods to profile and instrument server side code". Is Server Timing part of that? If yes, then we need to update the out of scope section as well.

yoavweiss commented 7 years ago

The "out of scope" section includes "methods to profile and instrument server side code". Is Server Timing part of that? If yes, then we need to update the out of scope section as well.

I don't think Server Timing is at odds with that scope exclusion. At most, Server Timing gives means to report server side profiling results to the client.

plehegar commented 7 years ago

One more thing: the previous charter did contain Server Timing and had the same out of scope. If we concluded at the time that Server Timing isn't prohibited by the out of scope, then no further change is needed.

plehegar commented 7 years ago

@yoavweiss thanks. Then no change is needed.

plehegar commented 7 years ago

I had further discussions with legal folks on my side about whether my past assumptions on the need for a new charter when adding new deliverables. It appears that, as long as it's within the scope section of the charter, we don't need a new charter before proceeding and I was simply incorrect to assume otherwise. As long as everyone in the Working Group agree that it's in scope, we can proceed.

igrigorik commented 7 years ago

@plehegar thanks, good to know. In which case, do we still want to update the charter and land these updates?

plehegar commented 7 years ago

Nope, no need to update the charter. You can publish the drafts as soon as you have a group decision to do so. Apologizes for my past misguidance :(

toddreifsteck commented 7 years ago

This LGTM. Merging.