w3c / contact-picker

Contact Picker API
https://www.w3.org/TR/contact-picker/
Other
74 stars 8 forks source link

Editorial: Add Contacts API history note #58

Closed anssiko closed 1 year ago

anssiko commented 1 year ago

Fix https://tantek.com/2020/026/t2


Preview | Diff

anssiko commented 1 year ago

Related TAG discussion: https://github.com/w3ctag/tag.w3.org/issues/22

Further work on top of this would be to expand this note with a (brief) explanation on what differentiates this proposal from the past efforts that did not gain traction. The spec editors are in the best position to do so.

marcoscaceres commented 1 year ago

Oh, I found this (in the README): https://github.com/w3c/contact-picker/pull/31/

I wonder if we should just migrate that over from the README?

anssiko commented 1 year ago

Updated to explain what differentiates this proposal from the past.

rayankans commented 1 year ago

I think the community just generally got better at designing these things, even if those APIs didn't get any look at when this new API was designed.

Kind of, all of the previous attempts were designed with full & perpetual access (gated by a permission) in mind, which is far from ideal, and contact edit access, which is not a use-case we found any legitimate interest in. These fundamental differences made us decide to start a new proposal rather than build on top of the previous ones.

maybe we can should move this into an Acknowledgments section?

+1, that seems like a more appropriate place

anssiko commented 1 year ago

Moved to an Acknowledgments section.

anssiko commented 1 year ago

@tantek friendly ping. Do you think this PR will address your issue documented in https://tantek.com/2020/026/t2

anssiko commented 1 year ago

Thanks @marcoscaceres for the improvements and review.

@tantek any last-minute suggestions before we merge this? I think it is helpful to have this text in the spec so future generations will find the prior work and can learn from it. Thanks for raising this issue in your blog to begin with.

anssiko commented 1 year ago

I'll merge this Acknowledgments update and we will capture any additional feedback in subsequent PRs.

@tantek if this PR does not address your initial concern, please let us know.