add ctid method - Githubissues

w3c / did-extensions

Decentralized Identifier Ecosystem Extensions

https://w3c.github.io/did-extensions/

Other

120 stars 196 forks source link

add ctid method #559

Closed 617640999 closed 4 months ago

617640999 commented 6 months ago

DID Method Registration

As a DID method registrant, I have ensured that my DID method registration complies with the following statements:

[x] The DID Method specification defines the DID Method Syntax.
[x] The DID Method specification defines the Create, Read, Update, and Deactivate DID Method Operations.
[x] The DID Method specification contains a Security Considerations section.
[x] The DID Method specification contains a Privacy Considerations section.
[x] The JSON file I am submitting has passed all automated validation tests below.
[x] The JSON file contains a contactEmail address [OPTIONAL].
[x] The JSON file contains a verifiableDataRegistry entry [OPTIONAL].

617640999 commented 5 months ago

In method-specific-identifier section I'd like a little more explanation about method-specific-id. Of course, we can know SM3 format by reading SM3 specification, but I'd like some information on length, etc.

Example
method-specific-id = <hexdigit>{64}
hexdigit = [0-9A-F]

I have modified the explanation about method-specific-id in https://github.com/617640999/ctid-did-register/commit/e44aa3d50cf199726122edadd7431d0fc918c1fb, please check again whether it meets the registration requirements. Thanks!

617640999 commented 5 months ago

Is it possible to clearly dissociate the security aspects from the privacy considerations in the last section? Please, try to clearly point out in the security part as present in the document at https://w3c.github.io/did-core/#security-requirements

Thanks for your review, I have updated my registration request to split security and privacy considerations into two points. Please help review again. link to this registration

617640999 commented 5 months ago

Could you please review it for me? @msporny @MizukiSonoko @gatemezing @ajile-in @genaris @KDean-Dolphin @apuchitnis @adam-burns @stenreijers @Steffytan @rajivrajani

617640999 commented 5 months ago

Please add more to the security and privacy considerations sections. For an example look at DID Core:
* https://www.w3.org/TR/did-core/#security-considerations

* https://www.w3.org/TR/did-core/#privacy-considerations

Thank a lot for your review. I have revised it. Please review it again. here is the link

617640999 commented 4 months ago

My registration has been approved twice. Could you please help me merge this PR ？ @msporny