search

w3c / did-resolution

RELEASED DRAFT: Decentralized Identifier Resolution (DID Resolution) 0.2 Specification
https://w3c.github.io/did-resolution/
Other
14 stars 9 forks source link

Service Endpoint Construction inconsistency #61

Open clehner opened 3 years ago

clehner commented 3 years ago

The example (https://w3c-ccg.github.io/did-resolution/#example-11) is inconsistent with the algorithm (https://w3c-ccg.github.io/did-resolution/#algorithm).

The example says:

Given the following input service endpoint URL:

https://example.com/messages/8377464

And given the following input DID URL:

did:example:123456789abcdefghi?service=messages&relative-ref=%2Fsome%2Fpath%3Fquery#frag

Then the output service endpoint URL is:

https://example.com/messages/8377464/some/path?query#frag

But by following the algorithm, I get this as the output URL:

https://example.com/messages/8377464?service=messages&relative-ref=%2Fsome%2Fpath%3Fquery#frag

It looks like in the example the relative-ref DID parameter is used instead of (or in addition to) the input DID URL path and query.

There is also an example in did-core (https://w3c.github.io/did-core/#example-9) for "A resource external to a DID Document", using service and relativeRef:

did:example:123?service=agent&relativeRef=/credentials#degree

Is using relativeRef/relative-ref the way to go? If so, how should it interact with the path component and other query parameters in service endpoint construction?

koptan commented 5 months ago

I am also facing the same issue somehow, for me, when I followed the algorithm I got the following as an output: https://example.com/messages/8377464/some/path?query#frag because in algorithm is not mentioning anything about relative-ref so simply I ignored :)

but I don't think this correct, because relative-ref should be part of the final result.

@clehner how did you solve this issue?

clehner commented 5 months ago

@koptan In the Service Endpoint Construction algorithm I use the path and query component from the decoded relativeRef parameter if present rather than from the input DID URL.

https://github.com/spruceid/ssi/blob/80a3f24bc721eba38d150c2912443b9a97cfe71e/src/did_resolve.rs#L549 (2021-02-02)

This should comply with the examples and the definition of relativeRef https://www.w3.org/TR/2022/REC-did-core-20220719/#did-parameters