search

w3c / did-rubric

W3C Decentralized Characteristics Rubric v1.0
https://w3c.github.io/did-rubric/
Other
14 stars 16 forks source link

the Rubric has moved beyond decentralization #54

Open rxgrant opened 2 years ago

rxgrant commented 2 years ago

While this rubric allows the evaluation of many aspects of decentralization of a DID Method, it is not exhaustive, and does not cover other factors that may affect selection or adoption of a particular Method, such as privacy, security, reliability, or efficiency.

This issue asks the editors/WG to acknowledge an expansion of scope.

The Rubric is a collection of criteria for creating Evaluation Reports that assist end users to choose DID Methods. The criteria are refereed by the Rubric editor, but evaluation invites opinions from anyone.

It definitely covers privacy and security, while reliability is contemplated, and efficiency is in the works due to the discovery of more intractable differences.

In order for Evaluation Reports to work well, the criteria will have to grow to be fairly exhaustive.

see pull #55

rxgrant commented 2 years ago

If a decentralization rubric should remain separate from a TAG/EWP rubric, now is a good time to separate them.

I would recommend not separating them.