search

w3c / dpub-pwp-ucr

Use Cases and Requirements for (Packaged) Web Publications
https://w3c.github.io/dpub-pwp-ucr/
Other
11 stars 14 forks source link

9.3 Building a Custom PWP #134

Closed marcoscaceres closed 7 years ago

marcoscaceres commented 8 years ago

Section "9.3 Building a Custom PWP" should be retitled "9.3 Building a Custom Reading Experience". Also, the use case for Buffy applies generally to everyone with a limited data plan (or limited time to read something).

iherman commented 8 years ago

I would agree with this: the issue is not build a new PWP but to build and alternative, or custom, reading approach in terms of a different ToC, for example.

Cc: @clapierre

marcoscaceres commented 8 years ago

Different ToCs is fine, but the requirement is really then about having the ability to generate alternative ToCs on the fly.

Would be good to gather real examples of publications that do this, so we can look at them in detail.

lrosenthol commented 8 years ago

@clapierre may not be happy with it, but in my latest draft, I removed this entire section (well, commented it out). The reason I did so is that a PWP can't do this - it's not a requirement of a PWP. If anything, this is a use case that we want to ensure isn't prevented by the technical choices of PWP - but in and of itself, it's not specific to either PWP or the UA's for same.

clapierre commented 8 years ago

ACTION: Charles will move one of our use-cases that was commented out into Rec20 after Heather has finished updating the gh_pages branch from Leonard.

iherman commented 7 years ago

It is now part of #157, including Charles' changes