himorin
commented
3 months ago filed one issue on string match. I see no other.
Closed msporny closed 3 months ago
himorin
commented
3 months ago filed one issue on string match. I see no other.
msporny
commented
3 months ago filed one issue on string match. I see no other.
Great, thank you @himorin!
I don't see the issue yet, can you include a pointer to it here?
In any case, we will process the issue before going to CR.
aphillips
commented
3 months ago Completed. The issue found was non-I18N
Name of your specification
Controllers Documents v1.0
URL of your specification
https://w3c.github.io/controller-document/
Does your specification include an Internationalization Considerations section?
When does the review need to be finished?
2024-09-02
What has changed since any previous review?
The Controller Documents v1.0 specification is a generalization of DID Documents and some content from VC Data Integrity. All this to say, horizontal review has occurred for most of this content before when it was in DID Core, and then again when it was in Verifiable Credential Data Integrity. The Working Group recently decided that it would rather have this content in a separate specification than embed it in DID Core or VC Data Integrity, and that specification is Controller Documents v1.0. 90%+ of the content remains the same as when it was reviewed previously before entering CR.
Please point to the results of your own self-review
https://github.com/w3c/controller-document/issues/24
Where and how should the i18n WG raise issues?
https://github.com/w3c/controller-document/issues/
Pointer to any explainer for the spec
Other comments
It is unclear if i18n should spend much time on this specification since it's largely composed of text that has been reviewed by i18n multiple times over the past several years.