Tone down statement - Githubissues

w3c / identity-web-impact

This document proposes an overview of Digital Identities on the Web and an analysis through different use cases of the systemic impact on both the market side and the human side, as well as the role that Web standardization may play in managing that impact

https://www.w3.org/reports/identity-web-impact/

1 stars 4 forks source link

Tone down statement #1

Closed koalie closed 1 month ago

koalie commented 1 month ago

"W3C is handling this issue with a Threat Model." implies endorsement by W3C members. But the link brings the reader to a use case within the document, which attempts to summarize an introduction to "Trust over IP" from 2021 by the "trust over IP foundation" which is a 35-page PDF hosted elsewhere.

This is misleading and risky to make such a claim and to rely on a document whose status is unclear at a cursory glance.

simoneonofri commented 1 month ago

The question is:

indentity impacts human rights > let's analyze with a threat model
- who should actively participate in the threat model? also governments I like ToIP because it takes a broader view than just the concept of credentials.