Open r12a opened 4 years ago
r12a
commented
4 years ago The first comment in this issue contains text that will automatically appear in one or more gap-analysis documents as a subsection with the same title as this issue. Any edits made to that comment will be immediately available in the document. Proposals for changes or discussion of the content can be made in comments below this point.
Relevant gap analysis documents include: _Bengali • Devanagari • Gujarati_
r12a
commented
3 years ago I rewrote this topic completely, applying the latest template. It introduces one aspect of the conjunct parsing problem that is a fundamental issue in many Brahmi derived scripts, and surfaces in other operations too, such as letter-spacing, line-breaking, etc.
r12a
commented
3 years ago Removed the information about handling clusters with visible viramas into https://github.com/w3c/iip/issues/115, which reduces the complexity here.
This issue is applicable to most languages that form conjuncts from consonant clusters using an invisible virama.
When the start of a line contains a consonant cluster that uses a conjunct (rather than visible virama), ::first-letter should highlight the whole cluster.
Consonant clusters that form conjuncts using an invisible virama between the component letters need to be selected as a unit. This doesn't work well if segmentation relies on Unicode grapheme clusters, since a conjunct with two consonants will be parsed as two grapheme clusters (the first ending after the virama, and the second starting with the second consonant and including any following vowel-signs or other combining characters).
For these situations it is necessary to tailor the segmentation algorithm, so that it recognises the whole consonant cluster plus any attached vowel-signs or combining characters as a single unit.
For examples see Typographic character units in complex scripts.
Specs:
css-text-3 CSS uses the concept of 'typographic character unit', rather than grapheme cluster, in its specs with the explanation that the cases just described go beyond the scope of the grapheme cluster concept and that implementations should provide appropriate support. The spec doesn't provide details about the support needed for each language.
The Unicode Consortium made some attempts to address this issue, but it has so far not yielded results. CLDR now flags up a few scripts for which conjuncts are common.
Tests & results: Interactive test, When ::first-letter is applied to Devanagari the browser will select a 2-consonant conjunct as a unit
Interactive test, When ::first-letter is applied to Bengali the browser will select a conjunct as a unit, if the virama is hidden
I18n test suite, Devanagari text
Browser bug reports:
Gecko
Priority: Keeping conjuncts together is a pretty basic requirement. Without a fix for this, authors need to manually mark up text to apply initial letter styling, but that isn't a very useful workaround.