search

w3c / imsc-hrm

IMSC Hypothetical Render Model
https://w3c.github.io/imsc-hrm/spec/imsc-hrm.html
Other
1 stars 6 forks source link

Define error and add Error and Exception appendix #40

Closed nigelmegitt closed 2 years ago

nigelmegitt commented 2 years ago

Appendix is informative and describes Error Reporting and Exception Handling.

Closes #29.

Preview | Diff

nigelmegitt commented 2 years ago

@pes10k this has reached our 14 day review minimum period, so we'd like to progress it, and would really appreciate your review feedback to confirm if it addresses the issue (#29), when you're able to take a look.

pes10k commented 2 years ago

We have this on the agenda for the PING chairs call on Monday. I will follow up with you all on Monday after that call

On Mar 4, 2022, at 05:51, Nigel Megitt @.***> wrote:

@pes10k this has reached our 14 day review minimum period, so we'd like to progress it, and would really appreciate your review feedback to confirm if it addresses the issue (#29), when you're able to take a look.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. Triage notifications on the go with GitHub Mobile for iOS or Android. You are receiving this because you were mentioned.

npdoty commented 2 years ago

I'm helping to review with @pes10k and expect to have feedback by Wednesday (9 March 2022).

npdoty commented 2 years ago

Commented on issue #29. This PR doesn't specify error handling behavior in much detail, which could have implications for applications that use it, but I suspect privacy and security impacts are very limited.

nigelmegitt commented 2 years ago

@pes10k @npdoty thank you, looking at these comments and the comment on #29, my understanding is:

  1. there are no major outstanding concerns after merging this pull request
  2. in your experience there are risks associated with not defining error handling behaviour in more detail, but the impact of those is not likely to be significant in the realm of privacy and security for the web in general - for which, thank you for your considered thoughts.

On that basis I will merge this; if there are additional changes needed I would ask that they are opened as new issues.