w3c / market-data-odrl-profile

Rights Automation for Market Data W3C Community Group
Other
4 stars 6 forks source link

Something better than Creditor/Debtor #17

Closed markabird closed 3 years ago

markabird commented 4 years ago

So far, we've used the terms "Debtor" and "Creditor" when discussing Duties. The Debtor is the party that has the responsibility to fulfill the Duty for the benefit (or at the insistence) of the Creditor. This makes logical sense because the Debtor "owes" some action to the Creditor.

However, these terms can be confusing because we're used to thinking about creditors and debtors in a monetary sense, where the debtor has an obligation to pay to the creditor. But in our parlance, the Debtor can be the party that "owes" the creation of an invoice to the Creditor. In this case, before the invoice is created, the Debtor is the party that has to make the invoice in order to get paid!

Let's use this thread to suggest other term pairs that can be used when describing Duties. What two terms most clearly define the party that requires a Duty, and the party to whom falls the responsibility of fulfilling the Duty?

Please submit suggestions below, and then we'll agree on a favorite on Wednesday's call.

jo-rabin-db commented 4 years ago

Some thing like: actor -> target giver -> receiver subject -> object

benedictws commented 4 years ago

Obligatee -> Obligator - ugly words, but the meaning fits perfectly

jo-rabin-db commented 4 years ago

Does obligator actually mean what we need it to mean?

obligatee (plural obligatees). A person who is obligated by law to do something

that's is OK for the party on whom there is a duty

obligator (plural obligators) (law) One who establishes an obligation under law

that reads like it's the person setting the obligation rather than the target of the action carried out as part of the obligation

epritce commented 4 years ago

Licensor-> Licensee

markabird commented 4 years ago

It's clumsy but how about:

Requiring Party -> Responsible Party

benedictws commented 4 years ago

Three worked examples:

Actor/Receiver Usage notification example

  1. The actor must notify the receiver when they first use the data

Audit example (roles swap between steps)

  1. The actor must notify the receiver of their desire to audit data usage.

  2. The actor must consent to the receiver's audit of their data usage within 30 days.

Subject/Object Usage notification example

  1. The subject of the duty must notify the object of the duty when they first use the data

Audit example (roles swap between steps)

  1. The subject of the duty must notify the object of the duty of their desire to audit data usage.

  2. The subject of the duty must consent to the object of the duty's audit of their data usage within 30 days.

Promisor/Promisee Usage notification example

  1. The promisor must notify the promisee when they first use the data

Audit example (roles swap between steps)

  1. The promisor must notify the promisee of their desire to audit data usage.

  2. The promisor must consent to the promisee's audit of their data usage within 30 days.