search

w3c / matf

Other
5 stars 0 forks source link

Success Criterion 1.2.2 - Captions (Prerecorded) - Level A #18

Open JJdeGroot opened 2 weeks ago

JJdeGroot commented 2 weeks ago

Discussion:

MATF meeting on June 19, 2024 [Source](https://www.w3.org/2024/06/19-matf-minutes.html#t04) JJ: Already partially discussed Quintin: We should mention to respect the OS user settings Quintin: Do captions need to identify speakers and significant sounds? JJ: Is there a difference or difference in guidance from the Web 1.2.2? JJ: Mostly on Web captions are not being picked up Detlev: Players not picking up captions: Is this an app or browsing context? Quitin: Native players provided out-of-the-box on Android/iOS Detlev: so it's mostly guidance for the videoplayer creators vs developers Agree JJ: Perhaps provide guidance to facilitate understanding

Summary:

  1. Respecting OS User Settings:

    • Quintin: Emphasized the importance of mentioning to respect the OS user settings in mobile app development.

  2. Identification in Captions:

    • Quintin: Raised the question of whether captions need to identify speakers and significant sounds.

  3. Guidance Differences:

    • JJ: Asked if there are differences or specific guidance from Web 1.2.2 regarding caption usage in mobile apps.
    • Detlev: Inquired about issues where players do not pick up captions, clarifying if this is in an app or browsing context.
    • Quintin: Noted that it's about native players which are provided out-of-the-box on Android/iOS platforms.
    • Detlev: Suggested that guidance primarily applies to video player creators rather than developers.
    • JJ: Proposed providing guidance to facilitate better understanding in implementing captions effectively.
JJdeGroot commented 2 weeks ago

Related issue: https://github.com/w3c/matf/issues/19