search

w3c / maturity-model

Maturity Model
https://w3c.github.io/maturity-model/
Other
17 stars 7 forks source link

Dimension Evaluation Instructions Are Problematic #232

Open Helixopp opened 5 days ago

Helixopp commented 5 days ago

When updating the Maturity Model draft we agreed to include instructions on how to use the "experimental" spreadsheet. We did not agree to embed the "experimental" spreadsheet as part of the process to evaluate Dimensions.

The following steps 1 - 3 have been embedded in every dimension. They need to be edited to explain that if a user wants to use the spreadsheet these are instructions on how to do so. However, the spreadsheet is not a part of the draft guidance:

  1. Download the maturity model spreadsheet.

  2. List all the organization's...

  3. Compare the list to the spreadsheet to decide which proof points will be used to assess your organization's accessibility maturity. Not all proof points will be used for every business or organization. The proof points are non-exhaustive examples of criteria.

Helixopp commented 5 days ago

@JaninaSajka @sheribyrne

Helixopp commented 3 days ago

How to evaluate, for all Dimensions, should be something like the below example:

  1. Decide which proof points will be used to assess your organization's [Dimension] accessibility maturity. Not all proof points may apply to every business or organization. The proof points listed here are non-exhaustive examples of criteria. They may, or may not apply. You may identify other proof points in their place and/or additional proof points.

  2. List all of the organization's documentation in relation to the identified proof points.

  3. Determine what accessibility maturity level your proof point documentation supports for {that Dimension].