search

w3c / mnx

Music Notation CG next-generation music markup proposal.
179 stars 18 forks source link

Why "The note value base object" supports "2048th", "4096th","duplexMaxima"? #353

Closed sunmoondevlab closed 2 months ago

sunmoondevlab commented 2 months ago

Why "The note value base object" supports "2048th", "4096th","duplexMaxima"?

See also Smufl Noteheads (U+E0A0–U+E0FF) and Smufl Flags.

Not supported "duplexMaxima" noteheads, and "2048th", "4096th" flags.

mscuthbert commented 2 months ago

I'm not sure what the question here is. SMuFL and MNX are related in being by the same working group, but they are not the same product. There will definitely be things that MNX supports that are not representable in SMuFL and almost certainly (at least in v.1) vice-versa.

sunmoondevlab commented 2 months ago

I'm not sure what the question here is. SMuFL and MNX are related in being by the same working group, but they are not the same product. There will definitely be things that MNX supports that are not representable in SMuFL and almost certainly (at least in v.1) vice-versa.

Thank you for your answer.

Since it is not supported by SmuFL, there is a possibility that it cannot be exported to printable sheet music (mainly in PDF format).

That is why I asked the question.

No point in "duplexMaxima" existing if we don't know how it will be expressed as sheet music.

sunmoondevlab commented 2 months ago

The application "Finale" supports 1/4096. I just noticed that. So does that mean support for 2048 and 4096 is necessary? I understand. I will close this issue.