w3c / musicxml

MusicXML specification
519 stars 57 forks source link

incorrect `DebuMandSample` #562

Open lemzwerg opened 2 weeks ago

lemzwerg commented 2 weeks ago

[I'm not sure whether this is the right place to report problems with files from musicxml-samples.zip]

The rendering as shown in DebuMandSample.pdf doesn't reflect the actual contents of DebuMandSample.mxl. Note the position of the 'pp' sign in the distributed PDF:

image

However, the horizontal position of 'pp' is not what is actually contained in DebuMandSample.mxl: In this file the dynamics symbol is clearly positioned after the first note.

Re-loading the MusicXML file into Finale gives the following, correct result.

image

(Note, however, that the lower fermata is incorrectly positioned in the second image; it explicitly has the type="upright" attribute and thus should be positioned as in the first image.)