search

w3c / opentrack-cg

Open Athletics Community Group
https://w3c.github.io/opentrack-cg/
Other
27 stars 6 forks source link

Status of Competition #16

Closed espinr closed 7 years ago

espinr commented 7 years ago

I've listed possible statuses of competitions (https://github.com/w3c/opentrack-cg/blob/master/spec/model/overview.md#event-status).

Code Status
Unscheduled Competition is not confirmed.
Scheduled Competition is scheduled.
Postponed Competition will be postponed without being rescheduled yet.
Rescheduled Competition is rescheduled.
Scheduled Break Competition has a scheduled break.
Running Competition in progress.
Interrupted Competition interrupted once in progress.
Getting Ready The start of the competition is imminent
Finished Competition is over and no more action will happen on the field of play (last competitor finished).
Cancelled Competition will not take place
Completed ???

@captainrobbo , I included all from OpenAth. I found that 'Completed' overlaps with 'Finished' (specified by IOC). Can we remove completed and use finished instead?

captainrobbo commented 7 years ago

On 16 May 2017 at 10:47, Martin Alvarez-Espinar notifications@github.com wrote:

I've listed possible statuses of competitions (https://github.com/w3c/ opentrack-cg/blob/master/spec/model/overview.md#event-status). Code Status Unscheduled Competition is not confirmed. Scheduled Competition is scheduled. Postponed Competition will be postponed without being rescheduled yet. Rescheduled Competition is rescheduled. Scheduled Break Competition has a scheduled break. Running Competition in progress. Interrupted Competition interrupted once in progress. Getting Ready The start of the competition is imminent Finished Competition is over and no more action will happen on the field of play (last competitor finished). Cancelled Competition will not take place Completed ???

@captainrobbo https://github.com/captainrobbo , I included all from OpenAth. I found that 'Completed' overlaps with 'Finished' (specified by IOC). Can we remove completed and use finished instead?

Sure. We will do a big overhaul of athlib in June to match your models and codes.

Again, contexts matter. The above make sense from the viewpoing of a TV broadcaster. But to a statistician, or official, or the public looking at a results website, we need the following concepts at "race level":

The distinction between the last two is important. I wonder if a separate field "resultsStatus" is a better way to cover it?

espinr commented 7 years ago

Indeed, I've just created a new set of result statuses:

Code Status
START_LIST Before competition, Start List
LIVE For live updates during competition
INTERMEDIATE When competition is stopped, usued at pre-defined points
UNCONFIRMED When the unit is over but not yet unofficial or official. Only used if other statuses do not come quickly.
UNOFFICIAL Results of the competition released as soon as the event is over, not waiting any official decision of the International Federation. The correctness of data must be assured.
OFFICIAL Results of the competition released as soon as the event is officially confirmed taking into account the resolution of the protests, etc.
PARTIAL Incomplete list, Final Ranking.
PROTESTED After the competition is no longer LIVE and a protest has been lodged After all decisions on the protest are made the ResultStatus will change to UNOFFICIAL or OFFICIAL as appropriate.