search

w3c / process

W3C Process Document
https://www.w3.org/policies/process/drafts/
182 stars 123 forks source link

We need to consider equal-preference voting #115

Open dwsinger opened 6 years ago

dwsinger commented 6 years ago

We seem to have a strong desire to have it, but the open-source software doesn't support it. If we can't have it, do we have the right voting system?

michaelchampion commented 6 years ago

If we can't have it, do we have the right voting system?

No. I will be opposing removing the “one vote per available seat” language until this is resolved. I supported STV in Process 2017 under the naive assumption that the team implemented the process as written with the one vote per available seat constraint. During the years of discussion, I can’t recall or find anyone mentioning that the STV software being used was inconsistent with the widely used practice of voting for slates of candidates rather than forcing an arbitrary ranking. If the process as written is inconsistent with STV theory or software implementation, I’d prefer the old system.

On Oct 17, 2017, at 2:33 AM, David Singer notifications@github.com wrote:

We seem to have a strong desire to have it, but the open-source software doesn't support it. If we can't have it, do we have the right voting system?

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/w3c/w3process/issues/115, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AD8uXm6z26jJALFGbjnhDy_RxJKLVa-Zks5stHRYgaJpZM4P72aF.

chaals commented 5 years ago

If we don't have it we have a suboptimal version of the right voting system, but we could improve it significantly by implementing equal ranking.

Ad-Huikeshoven commented 5 years ago

Hi. You are looking for open source STV software that allows equal rankings. You can consider https://github.com/nealmcb/flexstv. This software has been used several times in elections for Affilisate Selected Board Seats of the Wikimedia Foundation. Have a nice day.