search

w3c / pwpub

W3C packaged Web Publications
https://w3c.github.io/pwpub/
Other
15 stars 9 forks source link

Better define LPF's UA conformance #46

Closed rdeltour closed 5 years ago

rdeltour commented 5 years ago

(This is a follow-up issue of the discussion we had at the Boston f2f. /cc @llemeurfr).

The UA Conformance requirements is currently underspecified, for instance:

It is able to import the Package and fulfill the same requirements as a user agent processing the equivalent Web Publication, as defined in [wpub-ucr] ;

Beyond the reference to a Note (which I guess is OK, LPF being a Note itself!), I believe we should define more precisely which requirements are meant here, and how a UA is expected to process the LPF to meet them.

It is able to expose the Package as a Web Publication, as defined in [wpub];

We don't define "expose something as a Web Publication" in the Web Publication spec, so we need to disambiguate what is meant here.

It is able to convert a Package to an alternative format suitable for electronic distribution.

Needs to be disambiguated as well. What does "suitable for electronic distribution" mean?

llemeurfr commented 5 years ago

Will be solved by #36

iherman commented 5 years ago

This issue was discussed in a meeting.