w3c / sdw

Repository for the Spatial Data on the Web Working Group
https://www.w3.org/2020/sdw/
149 stars 81 forks source link

WebVMT: Review map block interface exposure #1100

Closed rjksmith closed 5 years ago

rjksmith commented 5 years ago

@tidoust wrote:

The WebVMT map definition block is interesting because the information it contains needs to be exposed to Web applications somehow, and there is no mechanism to do so for now. That is, even if browsers could parse and expose WebVMT cues as DataCue or as a specific VMTCue, the map information would still need to be exposed somehow. I'd raise that as an open issue at least.

rjksmith commented 5 years ago

The WebVMT map block is analogous to the WebVTT region block, as it describes the area for rendered output. WebVTT exposes regions through the WebVTT region interface and I'd expect WebVMT would have an equivalent interface.

I agree that this is an omission from the current Editor's Draft and should be added.

rjksmith commented 5 years ago

SDW IG Review Summary (5/12/18)

This is an omission and the WebVMT map block should be exposed.

Conclusion

rjksmith commented 5 years ago

Updated Editor's Draft - pull request #1105:

Formal API definition is separate from the Data Model and Syntax sections, and so beyond the scope of the 5/12/18 review. I've added an informal draft for now, to serve as a starting point for the formal definition in due course.