w3c / sealreq

Southeast Asian layout task force
34 stars 5 forks source link

Drop caps in Javanese #12

Open adtbayuperdana opened 6 years ago

adtbayuperdana commented 6 years ago

Ilham Nurwansyah recently point me to this book, Dongeng-dongeng Pingĕntĕngĕn by Muhammad Musa, printed in 1867. (most pages are available in google books). It is a collection of tales written in the Sundanese language using the Javanese script. I have not encountered Javanese drop caps in other books, so this might be an exceptional case. Hopefully these samples would be useful for documentation.

javanese drop caps dongeng-dongeng pingentengen 1867

r12a commented 6 years ago

@adtbayuperdana Since you haven't encountered this elsewhere, is there some connection with the fact that it's Sundanese? Just checking... @Ilhamkang, do you happen to know whether this is something that happens when people use the Sundanese script ?

Ilhamkang commented 6 years ago

@r12a No, I haven't encountered it. The drop caps neither occurs on any available modern Sundanese script source-book nor in the old Sundanese manuscript.

adtbayuperdana commented 6 years ago

@r12a I have not seen a lot Sundanese book printed in the Javanese script; in fact, this is my first one. This book has many qualities that I did not find in my Javanese book resources, including:

  1. Very frequent use of Cecak Telu
  2. Frequent use of Pangrangkep
  3. Using Tarung as a replacement for Tolong vowel sign

I do not know whether these qualities are connected to the language, or peculiar to this book alone. Perhaps @Ilhamkang know of other Sundanese language/Javanese script books that we might compare with each other?

Ilhamkang commented 6 years ago

There is a good book resource about Javanese script for Sundanese language, written by K.F. Holle, published in 1862. Soendasch spel- en lees boek, met Soendasche letter – K. F. Holle.pdf

There are several printed book with Sunda-Javanese script on Google Book. Please find the following titles on Gbook:

r12a commented 6 years ago

My summary of this in the gap analysis document was:

Initial-letter styling of the kind that ressembles drop caps doesn't appear to be a feature of Javanese script (although there is one example of Sundanese written with the Javanese script).

https://w3c.github.io/sealreq/gap-analysis/java-gap.html#initialletter

Ilhamkang commented 6 years ago

Hi all, I've got another sample for Javanese drop cap on Sundanese language. This is a document from National Library of Indonesia, entitled "Mitra Noe Tani" volume 3 (unknown year, est. 1880's) by Moehammad Moesa, published by Landsdrukkerij in Batavia.

wangkongan hal kopi (page 1)

pg4 (page 4)

pg8 (page 8)

pg17 (page 17)

pg19 (page 19)

r12a commented 6 years ago

Interesting to see how decorative these are.

@Ilhamkang do documents written in Sundanese script happen to use drop caps too? Just wondering whether that could be an influence here.

Ilhamkang commented 6 years ago

@r12a Nope. There is no documents written in Sundanese script with drop caps found yet, and it should be younger than Sunda-Javanese printed book. The documents with drop caps in Sunda-Javanese script were published earlier than documents with modern Sundanese script.

In fact both of the Sunda-Javanese documents above written by the same author (Muhammad Musa) and same publisher (Landsdrukkerij). I'm wondering these were a kind of convention used by the author, typesetter and the publisher.