search

w3c / smufl

Standard Music Font Layout
https://w3c.github.io/smufl/latest/
214 stars 35 forks source link

Regarding issue #282 Add stylistic alternate for 19th century F clef #293

Open MrFuzzywump opened 3 hours ago

MrFuzzywump commented 3 hours ago 
          @MrFuzzywump -- it has been requested several times that you not continue to add more examples of these well known stylistic alternates to this issue.  Locking for now.  Any owner can unlock.

Originally posted by @mscuthbert in https://github.com/w3c/smufl/issues/282#issuecomment-2232222544

I will not continue to add more examples of these well known stylistic alternates to this issue and I am not continuing to add more examples of these well known stylistic alternates to this issue. How to unlock? Who will unlock? Would you be willing to unlock?

And I have just created a new name for this new glyph: F clef, turned C shape. What do you think?

MrFuzzywump commented 3 hours ago

I don't need to post more examples.

MrFuzzywump commented 2 hours ago

I was posting some 18th century examples because the issue has "19th century" in it. It was used mostly, if not only, before 1840. The "Before 1840 F clef" was used before 1840, hence the name, and in the 18th century. And we have disagreement on whether it's 18th century or 19th century. I would call it simply earlyModernFClef since we have disagreement on whether it's 18th century or 19th century and that term mostly covers either. The oldest example I sent was 1784. I just wanted to prove that it was (also) used in the 18th century. I would call it simply F clef, turned C shape.