SPARQL Query errata (3/5)

w3c / sparql-query

https://w3c.github.io/sparql-query/

Other

5 stars 0 forks source link

Open afs opened 1 year ago

afs commented 1 year ago

[ ] errata-query-10 - problem related to substitute
[x] errata-query-11 - fix for Aggregation()
[x] errata-query-12 - clarification in Diff; see also errata-query-7 and errata-query-7a
[x] errata-query-13 - correction (defn used correctly later)
[ ] errata-query-14 - clarification: explanation of "unaggregated variables"

hartig commented 1 year ago

Regarding errata-query-11, the main change suggested for this errata is unnecessary (or even problematic), as I argue in #94

However, the errata also includes another, smaller change suggestion:

In Definition: Aggregation replace "multiset of partial functions" by "set of partial functions".

This change has been implemented in PR #98.

afs commented 1 year ago

So can we tick-off the errata-query-11 task item? And close #94? (BTW a PR with "This close #" automates closing an issue when a PR is merged)

hartig commented 1 year ago

So can we tick-off the errata-query-11 task item? And close #94?

It depends whether people agree with my argument in #94. I have not seen anyone confirming that they agree ;-)

hartig commented 1 year ago

I have added PR #109 which implements what I think remains to be done for errata-query-11.

hartig commented 1 year ago

After merging PR #109, errata-query-11 is addressed now.