search

w3c / standards-track

Best Practices for Bringing Work to the W3C Recommendation Track
https://www.w3.org/Guide/standards-track/
10 stars 10 forks source link

target audience section doesn't include AC in decisions it shares with Director #14

Closed wayneca closed 8 years ago

wayneca commented 8 years ago

The target audience for this document includes:

  • the Team and Director when evaluating proposals to create new Working Groups or rechartering existing Working Groups to put new work in scope;
  • working group Chairs determining whether to publish First Public Working Drafts of specs that are in a group's chartered scope,
  • Advisory Committee representatives reviewing charters and Proposed Recommendations.

What the team and director consider should be the same as what the AC considers -- they both consider charters and PR - but the two bullets differ only by PR included in the Director bullet. It also should be clearer what about the charter should be considered.

Created PR for proposed wording change #13

Also - What should the Director consider at Proposed REC time? Seems the Director/AC look at the current draft and what kind of review and input it had, and at that point it doesn't matter if that was during incubation or after that as long as it was done by Proposed REC. There are already criteria for Proposed REC in the process. So I think that part should be clarified or removed.

michaelchampion commented 8 years ago

I accepted the pull request on this topic