Property names and values of TDM-a and TDM-b

w3c / tdm-reservation-protocol

Repository of the Text and Data Mining Reservation Protocol Community Group

https://www.w3.org/community/tdmrep/

Other

7 stars 8 forks source link

Property names and values of TDM-a and TDM-b #16

Closed llemeurfr closed 3 years ago

llemeurfr commented 3 years ago

It is now time for a "bike-shedding round": we have worked so far with two properties:

TDM-a is a flag with three values 0 = tdm rights are not reserved 1 = tdm rights are reserved 2 = tdm rights are reserved and a TDM policy is available
TDM-b is a URL, set only if mining is conditional, with points to a policy. The policy offers details on how to contact the rightsholder and give clues on what to expect.

What would be your preferred names and values for these properties?

llemeurfr commented 3 years ago

My very personal proposal is:

"tdm-signal" with values 0,1 or 2
"tdm-policy" as a URL.

Note that MDN on HTTP Headers specifies that we dont need to add an "X-" prefix anymore. We should still register "TDM-Signal" and "TDM-Policy" to IANA (the would appear in https://www.iana.org/assignments/message-headers).

ps: I hesitated with "tdm-flag" but flag is usually a boolean.

Jean-Baptiste-de-Vathaire commented 3 years ago

for tdm-a, an option could be "tdm-declaration" since it is a declaration of right's reservation.

Jean-Baptiste-de-Vathaire commented 3 years ago

Another option for the tdm-a could be "tdm-reservation".

RobinLeMaroisSeraphin commented 3 years ago

I agree with (i) tdm-declaration because it is self-explanatory and (ii) tdm-policy for tdm-b

claudiotubertini commented 3 years ago

I'm happy with tdm-signal and tdm-policy.

giuliamarangoni commented 3 years ago

Hi All, here's my proposals:

TDM_RightsReservation_Type

TDM_RightsReservation_Policy

The idea is to use the term RightsReservation for consistency with the art.4 terminology, The _Type suffix is meant to introduce a list of options (0-1-2), where 0 stands for: "no TDM rights reservation" 1 for " TDM rights are reserved" 2 for "TDM rights are reserved and license information are available" ( i think it is preferable to say "and" instead of "but", and say that information about licenses are available, as ORDL policy are not licenses but information on license)

llemeurfr commented 3 years ago

@giuliamarangoni, a caveat with your proposal is that the more characters there are, the more chances that a developer will mistype one character. And a bad character means no detection by TDM Agents. Plus the underscore is a character people tend to mistype.

giuliamarangoni commented 3 years ago

I see. Maybe we could cut "rights" to shorten it? on the underscore: no strong preference on this, also other separators are ok!

llemeurfr commented 3 years ago

We've used the acronym tdmrep from the start of this project. @giuliamarangoni would it be ok instead of tdm-rights?

llemeurfr commented 3 years ago

During the community call, the following terms have been chosen:

tdm-reservation tdm-policy