w3c / wai-website

This repository hosts the WAI Website.
https://www.w3.org/WAI/
Other
55 stars 246 forks source link

how indicate checks that require sight? #679

Open shawna-slh opened 1 year ago

shawna-slh commented 1 year ago

How do we want to indicate checks that require sight?

MicheleAWilliams-A11y commented 10 months ago

+1 - and also one's that require certain interaction (e.g., keyboard focus).

Related, I was a bit jarred by this statement: "You will be able to perform any of the following checks on any web page." Is it possible to revise this statement to set the tone for that??

"You can perform these checks on any web page, though note some checks will require being able to view the screen and use a keyboard."

shawna-slh commented 9 months ago

Hi @KosiAsabere Here is this existing issue

KosiAsabere commented 9 months ago

@iadawn @shawna-slh @MicheleAWilliams-A11y

I'm sure there's a way to make it less wordy, but how about something like this?

Disclaimer:

Certain accessibility checks are designed to evaluate how well a website can be navigated and understood visually and through keyboard use. These checks aim to ensure the website is accessible and user-friendly for those who rely on visual cues and keyboard navigation. However, individuals with vision-related disabilities or limited keyboard ability may find these specific checks challenging.

MicheleAWilliams-A11y commented 9 months ago

How about:

Certain accessibility checks evaluate visual cues and keyboard-only navigation that are important for many users. However, this means individuals with vision-related disabilities or limited keyboard ability may find these specific checks challenging.

shawna-slh commented 9 months ago

How do we want to indicate [which] checks that require sight?

I was thinking that each check needs some indication -- so that people who cannot do the check don't waste time going to that page.

KosiAsabere commented 9 months ago

This could be on the landing page:

code

Disclaimer:

Due to the nature of certain accessibility checks involving visual cues and keyboard or mouse use, they may pose challenges for users with visual or physical disabilities. Disclaimers with specific details can be found on the relevant pages.

KosiAsabere commented 9 months ago

@shawna-slh @iadawn @MicheleAWilliams-A11y These Other disclaimers could be used on each of the relevant pages (feel free to adjust the wording):

Disclaimer for Keyboard Navigation:

This accessibility check requires the use of a keyboard, which may pose challenges for some non-keyboard users.

Accessibility Disclaimer for Visual Checks:

This accessibility check is visual in nature and may present challenges for individuals with vision-related disabilities.

Accessibility Disclaimer for Mouse-Related Checks:

Parts of this accessibility check require the use of a mouse, which may be difficult for non-mouse users.

AndrewArch commented 9 months ago

Some checks will require hearing too, e.g. for sensible captions or transcripts