w3c / wcag-act

WCAG Accessibility Conformance Testing (ACT)
Other
53 stars 27 forks source link

How to update `audio` or `video` has no audio that plays automatically (80f0bf) #498

Closed carlosapaduarte closed 3 years ago

carlosapaduarte commented 3 years ago

Early feedback from the TF reveals that the "3 seconds" condition on the applicability and in one specific atomic rule is confusing.

There are, at least, 2 ways to address this:

  1. Rewrite the applicability in order to include what is now the expectation of the atomic rule Audio or video that plays automatically has no audio that lasts more than 3 seconds, that is, the rules would be applicable only when the audio lasts more than 3 seconds. This would mean this atomic rule would no longer be needed, and we would end up with just a single atomic rule: audio or video that plays automatically has a control mechanism

  2. Remove the 3 seconds condition from the applicability and keep the composite with the 2 atomic rules.

carlosapaduarte commented 3 years ago

Wrong place!