waldronlab / BugSigDBcuration

For documenting issues related to BugSigDB curation.
10 stars 7 forks source link

Microbial gut evaluation in an angolan paediatric population with sickle cell disease #452

Open Scholarpat opened 3 months ago

Scholarpat commented 3 months ago

Microbial gut evaluation in an angolan paediatric population with sickle cell disease - Mariana Delgadinho – J Cell Mol Med. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jcmm.17402

azizgueye47 commented 1 month ago

hi, I would like to work on this project @SvetlanaUP

Nathcynthia commented 1 month ago

Microbial gut evaluation in an angolan paediatric population with sickle cell disease - Mariana Delgadinho – J Cell Mol Med. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jcmm.17402

Good day, @SvetlanaUP can this paper be assigned to me @Cynthia Iwuoha

SvetlanaUP commented 1 month ago

This paper is under curation by @azizgueye47 @Nathcynthia please select other one.

AleruDivine commented 1 month ago

Hi @azizgueye47, hope you're doing well!

I wanted to check in and see how your curation is progressing. I'd be happy to help if you're having any challenges.

Thanks!

AleruDivine commented 1 month ago

Hello @azizgueye47, I'm checking in again. This study is yet to be added on BugSigDB, are you having any challenges curating this paper? I'll be more than happy to help you out.

Having gone through this paper briefly, I identified one experiment with signatures to be curated. Please feel free to reach out to me on Slack if you need help. @AleruDivine

In case you have difficulty getting the PMID, here's the PubMed link to the article, which also contains the PMID = 36168945

Thank you so much!

TheTosin commented 1 month ago

Hi @azizgueye47 I would like to know if you need assistance on creating this study.

16s, illumina. Group 0: 36 Healthy siblings Group 1: 36 SCA patients.

Figure 5 seems curatable. Relative abundance of the ten most prevalent bacterial genera between SCA children and corresponding healthy siblings.

You can reach me at @Adeshile Oluwatosin on slack. We can collaborate to make this curation faster. I hope to hear from you.

SvetlanaUP commented 1 month ago

@TheTosin please note Figure 5 is not of BugSigDB interest since we are curating statistically significant differences and differential abundances not prevalence.

Since @AleruDivine was the first one asking for this curation, it's assigned to Aleru. @TheTosin, you can do its peer review if you are still interested.

TheTosin commented 1 month ago

Thank you for clarifying @SvetlanaUP I would drop a peer review on slack.

AleruDivine commented 1 month ago

Thank you so much @SvetlanaUP I'll get started on curating the study.

I'll be sure to tag you once I'm finished @TheTosin

AleruDivine commented 1 month ago

Good evening @SvetlanaUP I'd like to put this study up for review. Link: https://bugsigdb.org/Study_1183

SvetlanaUP commented 9 hours ago

@KateRasheed https://github.com/KateRasheed could you please do review of this curation?

KateRasheed commented 9 hours ago

Thank you @SvetlanaUP . I would get on it.

KateRasheed commented 1 hour ago

Good evening @AleruDivine .

Welldone on your curation. Here are some corrections to be made on the study:

  1. The study design is cross-sectional not case-control
  2. Group 1 name for experiment 1 should be Sickle Cell Anaemia children(rather than Sickle Cell Anaemia cases)
  3. Clostridium XI is missing in experiment 1, signature 1
  4. MHT correction should be No

Thank you. @SvetlanaUP

AleruDivine commented 1 hour ago

Thank you so much for the review @KateRasheed I will go ahead to make the necessary corrections.

AleruDivine commented 33 minutes ago

Thanks again for the review @KateRasheed I’ve changed the following:

  1. Study design has been changed from case-control to cross-sectional observational, not case-control.
  2. Group 1 name has been updated to Sickle Cell Anaemia Children.
  3. MHT correction has been updated to NO (my apologies for the omission).

As for Clostridium XI, this isn’t missing. It is resolved as Peptostreptococcaceae with Taxonomy ID 186804.

@SvetlanaUP In addition, I also updated the alpha diversity (Shannon Index) I missed initially in experiment 1 between siblings and SS groups.

Thank you so much @KateRasheed 😊

KateRasheed commented 26 minutes ago

Thanks for the changes @AleruDivine .

@SvetlanaUP This study has been reviewed and everything is good.