search

wanghejin / pe

0 stars 0 forks source link

Unable to sort #9

Open wanghejin opened 9 months ago

wanghejin commented 9 months ago

After I did a filter operation, but found no one. Then I do bsort, nothing shows up. But in fact there are indeed many buyers in the list it's just I didn't use list to restore the list.

image.png

soc-pe-bot commented 9 months ago

Team's Response

Perhaps we could have made it more explicit that the commands work on lists with filters applied, but since the list command is available to restore the buyers and poses little inconvenience for users, we would be rejecting this bug as it doesn't fit the criteria of a feature flaws (not optimised enough, doesn't fit well, does not solve the stated problem). We designed the sort command to work with a filtered list as filter results can possibly return a large number of contacts that are matching, and so we can sort these contacts in the filtered list so as to identify those contacts from the filter results that we really want.

Items for the Tester to Verify

:question: Issue response

Team chose [response.Rejected]

Reason for disagreement: With all due respect and explanation from the dev team, I would like to stick to type.FeatureFlaw and argue for a severity.Low in this case.

  1. I fail to see how this feature presents a valid use case for realtors. The said use case of "sorting a filtered list", or simply the feature sorting, is not listed in the DG under either User Stories or Use Cases. Nor is it stated anywhere in the UG.
  2. Logically thinking, I fail to see why someone would want to sort the buyer/seller list by home address/house info/name in alphabetical order, ascending or descending, other than making the list view looks nicer. The use case is not intuitive to me at all.
  3. Moreover, for buyers of estates, their current home address or current house info should not matter at all to a real estate agent, since they will be buying new houses. Hence, sorting by those criteria seems meaningless to me.

Attached is a screenshot of the UG on bsort, the feature in my original bug report:

image.png

I am not sure what it means by "Elevate your contact list through organisation based on your priorities." It also did not give any scenario that enlightens me with any possible use case.

I admit that I have overlooked this given the tight time constraint in PE and I should have tweaked my bug report to fit better with the real underlying issue. However, I still believe that there is a legit feature flaw for the feature bsort