[speech-to-text] keywords, keywords_threshold, word_alternatives_threshold are being dropped

[monte-hayward]

The v1 service wrapper would pick params allowed to be sent to the service. This pr updates the "allowed" list with the new parameters announced in Updates for December 2015.

[ykcadcg]

what's a good keywords_threshold? 0 or 1 or 0.8 or else? It can't be left unspecified

C:\Users\kyang\Documents\GitHub\curl-7.49.0\AMD64>curl -X POST -u 27f6c1ee-3d03-4ef7-a4ea-c06877ad9d6b:Q03HBDFk07DP --header "Content-Type: audio/flac" --header "Transfer-Encoding: chunked" --data-binary @C:\Users\kyang\Documents\GitHub\0001.flac "
tps://stream.watsonplatform.net/speech-to-text/api/v1/recognize?continuous=true&keywords="actually""

{
   "code_description": "Bad Request",
   "code": 400,
   "error": "keywords_threshold must be set if keywords list is not empty."
}

[nfriedly]

Yea, the range is 0-1. I think we set it to 0.2 for the demo, but for real world usage, I would suggest a bit higher, maybe 0.5 or 0.8. It's basically a trade-off though - is it more important that you catch the keyword even if the speaker mumbled it (0.2) or that you avoid false-positives when they actually said something else (0.8). To some extent, you'll want to test different values and see what fits your app.

[ykcadcg]

Thank you! I have another quick question: I'm new to Java/JSON. My code adapting speech-android-wrapper. My this.sConfig.keywords is a public String[]. I know this toString() messed up with passing this.sConfig.keywords, but how to pass it correctly? I got error: "error": "Required type for parameter \"keywords\" is list. Got type unicode instead." Thanks! ` private void sendSpeechHeader() {

     JSONObject obj = new JSONObject();
     try {
         obj.put("action", "start");
         obj.put("content-type", this.sConfig.audioFormat);
         obj.put("interim_results", true);
         obj.put("continuous", true);
         obj.put("inactivity_timeout", this.sConfig.inactivityTimeout);
         obj.put("word_confidence", true); 
         obj.put("keywords_threshold", this.sConfig.keywordsThreshold); 
         obj.put("keywords", Arrays.toString(this.sConfig.keywords)); //this.sConfig.keywords is a  public String[]
     } catch (JSONException e) {
         e.printStackTrace();
     }
     String startHeader = obj.toString(); //I know this toString() messed up with passing this.sConfig.keywords, but how to pass it correctly?

     this.upload(startHeader);
     this.encoder.onStart();
     Log.d(TAG, "Sending init message: " + startHeader);
 }`

Got error: 05-29 16:25:53.078 28782-29008/com.ibm.watson.developer_cloud.android.examples D/MainActivity: onMessage, message: { "error": "Required type for parameter \"keywords\" is list. Got type unicode instead."

[ykcadcg]

btw the debugger for startHeader is this: {"action":"start","content-type":"audio\/ogg;codecs=opus","interim_results":true,"continuous":true,"inactivity_timeout":600,"word_confidence":true,"keywords_threshold":0.75,"keywords":"[banana, apple]"}

[ykcadcg]

Thanks. I also noticed during debugging: "final" is always "true" and never "false". Is it expected?

[nfriedly]

The final will always be true unless you set interim_results: true in the opening JSON message. Then you'll get a series of non-final "preview" results before each final one.

As for the Java thing, I'm not as familiar with that, but my guess is that it wants a JSONArray: https://developer.android.com/reference/org/json/JSONArray.html

[ykcadcg]

Got you, you are right, it needs JSONArray. thanks!