search

watsonbox / exportify

Export/Backup Spotify playlists using the Web API
https://exportify.app/
MIT License
3.15k stars 436 forks source link

Export Shows Similar Songs as Duplicates when they actualy are not #181

Closed bsper closed 2 months ago

bsper commented 2 months ago

Seeing an issue where the Exportify export will lump similar songs as the same when they are technically different tracks according to Spotify.

For example, I have a playlist with these two songs: Song Name Album Spotify URL
Kashmir - 1990 Remaster Physical Graffiti (1994 Remaster) https://open.spotify.com/track/2nVHqZbOGkKWzlcy1aMbE7?si=5fdb9a230c7f42b6
Kashmir - Remaster Physical Graffiti (Deluxe Edition) https://open.spotify.com/track/6Vjk8MNXpQpi0F4BefdTyq?si=8e1fd5dc174d408e

But when Exportify exports the playlist it just lists both songs as spotify:track:6Vjk8MNXpQpi0F4BefdTyq, so it thinks both are from the Album 'Physical Graffiti (Deluxe Edition)'

I have about 5 others songs that have similar issues and can list them out if it helps.

Don't know exactly when this behavior started, but it was not happening when I did a backup on 08/04/2024, but then it started when I did my next backup on 09/02/2024

watsonbox commented 2 months ago

You're quite right.. thanks for the report and very clear repro data. It came in as part of the changed is_market behavior in https://github.com/watsonbox/exportify/commit/9b0f396cb420e29b28857905db99f1aeb4c108d8. I've reverted that update for now to correct this bug, until I have time to see if it can be re-introduced without the same problem.