wax-office-of-inspector-general / waxguilds

WAX Guilds - Evaluation Reports and Discussions. Full scores released on notion:
https://www.notion.so/wax-oig/Guild-Ratings-0e51defdf10641748a253ccc7f5146b1
14 stars 81 forks source link

Wizards Guild January 2022 appeal #224

Closed BigMike690 closed 2 years ago

BigMike690 commented 2 years ago

We didn't include enough metrics in our original report.

DU$T sent out over 300,000 DU$T rewards this month.

We have over 17,500 token hodlers who generate approximately 75000 transactions every week, and 10,700 tx's every day.

The DU$T miner bot is in over 100 chats mostly from the wax community

Some of our bigger partners include:

Alien Worlds The Horrors Blockchain Heroes HodlGod ExitLimbo

Roadmap: -Distributing DU$T to other collections starting with Nifty Wizards Q1

Nifty Wizards

We have about 100-150 active players daily and 250 active monthly users.

We just completed our third Battle royale contest and we had our largest turnout ever at 48 participants.

Roadmap

Shyn

We have over 1000 downloads on both IOS and Android and we are working on adding analytics to the app so we can get MAU/DAU numbers.

Roadmap

Collectabot

Collectabot gets between 60 -100 calls per day and we had a very large spike this month in calls at one point which put us at a whopping 3.3 million calls this month.

Roadmap

kaefergeneral commented 2 years ago

As per the data we have been provided with, neither Dust nor NiftyWizards provide a significant impact on the WAX ecosystem to justify a higher score. We evaluate projects based on the following criteria:

Right now, none of your products check in any of these categories.

These criteria need to be supported by accurate progress reports and development plans. In the future, we urge you to limit your reports to the current evaluation period and not submit a multi-page long report that is mostly a copy of the previous month and proves inaccurate. Take your 'Collectabot' submission that has been unchanged for a long time as an example. For over half a year, with every evaluation, you reported that "Other sets have reached out to us to implement the bot with their set, and integration is ongoing.". But to this date, we have not seen any further integration.

Please also refrain from trying to bolster your report by claiming 'bigger partners' you have no ongoing relationship with, aside from your dust bot running on their community channels.

We will revisit Shyn as development progresses. But be aware that we have multiple feature-rich NFT Viewers on WAX already that are further advanced and established, while the usefulness of NFT Viewers in itself is already very limited. A multi-chain viewer is a new angle but will have to prove its worth.