search

wax-office-of-inspector-general / waxguilds

WAX Guilds - Evaluation Reports and Discussions. Full scores released on notion:
https://www.notion.so/wax-oig/Guild-Ratings-0e51defdf10641748a253ccc7f5146b1
14 stars 81 forks source link

RATING APPEAL #928

Closed dapplicaio closed 6 months ago

dapplicaio commented 6 months ago

Good Day IG's

Can you please have a look at the points we have awarded for the following:

  1. Dark Country - Not that clear why project is getting decay points, it's being doing better last months, trading volume was growing as reported. Also due to nature of our product, we propose automation so users dont need to click some parts of game daily if they buy a subscription, thus it means it might not show their onchain activities. Please take that intio consideration.
  2. Our atomicNotify bot wasn't added into contribution list - previously it was added always as a tool.

Thank you

kaefergeneral commented 6 months ago

Hello @dapplicaio,

thank you for notifying us about the bot. It was supposed to be marked for decay, but not be removed. This was fixed now.

As for Dark Country, even though the stats have increased, due to overall market conditions no decay was applied to it in over a year. We do recognise the effort going into it, at this stage we don't see a higher score being warranted. While the UAW have seen an increase, the overall trade volume and activity are still lagging behind. After some internal discussion we agreed to uphold the current score for the time being and not decay further.

best wishes, your OIG