Magellan vs Jetpack Navigation Safeargs

adellhk commented 2 years ago

Hi Magellan folks!

Would you be willing to contrast Magellan with Jetpack Navigation + SafeArgs?

e.g. a team is considering Jetpack Navigation, Magellan, or other OSS libraries for a greenfield project or a rewrite
It seems like Magellan journeys are similar to jetpack graphs
- Maybe I am misunderstanding nuance?
It seems like both allow typed arguments & extracting navigation from views
With Jetpack I can use the safeargs compiler plugin for sublime build speeds
Potentially Magellan allows more abstraction (navigator.goTo) than Jetpack navigation (NavController.navigate(someTypedAction)

Would you folks document the differences in your wiki, "Why Would I Use Magellan"?

ryanmoelter commented 2 years ago

Hey @adellhk, thanks for reaching out! That's a fantastic question. Either I or @cmathew will put a wiki page together soon and follow up here when it's done. :)

adellhk commented 2 years ago

Thank @ryanmoelter!

wealthfront / magellan

Magellan vs Jetpack Navigation Safeargs #222