search

websedit / we_cookie_consent

Cookie Consent Panel (Optin) with DSGVO/GDPR compliant use of cookies for TYPO3. Based on Klaro!.
3 stars 16 forks source link

Missing consent mode options for GTM #46

Open msollmann opened 3 months ago

msollmann commented 3 months ago

We only use the Google Tag Manager (record type "google-tagmanager") without GTM services (record type "google-tagmanager-service"), because all conversion trackings are configured inside GTM. Nevertheless we need to set the consent mode options (ad_storage, analytics_storage, ad_user_data, ad_personalization...). But these options are missing in the consent record "google-tagmanager". Can you provide these also for this record type?

Regards Michael

romanliedtke commented 2 months ago

Hello Michael,

that is an interesting approach.

In our opinion, however, this is not appropriate and also not data protection compliant according to GDPR. The Google Tag Manager is just a container for integrating other services. The services integrated via it (GA4, Google Ads, Conversions, etc.) should always be addressed individually or as the sum of a category (Statistics, Marketing, etc.) and with their required consent types. The GTM itself does not require any consent types from Google (as of today) and this is also mapped in the extension.

Regardless of this, you are free to make adjustments to the extension in your implementation. If it complies with your guidelines and your data protection, it might be possible to adjust the default consent states in the partial (\Resources\Private\Partials\Service\google-tagmanager.html). This could possibly work when using the “ConsentMode - Basic implementation”. However, we are left out here.

I hope this feedback helps you. Best regards Roman