Remove strange wikidata punctuation on location specifiers

[MansMeg]

See for example: Q5885293,"Kråkered," (now fixed)

We should not include location specifiers with punctuation if the ordinary name exist (like Kråkered in this case).

see: https://github.com/welfare-state-analytics/riksdagen-corpus/blob/main/corpus/metadata/location_specifier.csv

[ninpnin]

This is a problem upstream https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5885293

[MansMeg]

Yes. The question is how to solve this. I guess we would like to remove stuff in our corpus but that people might want to keep in wikidata, so that there will not be a perfect alignment with wikidata. Maybe add a csv with stuff we exclude from wikidata we add to the updating script from wikidata? Or do you have another solution?

[ninpnin]

I mean those misspellings could be just fixed on wikidata?

EDIT: AFAIK those additional commas don't introduce any errors to our corpus

[MansMeg]

No. I know. My point is that sooner or later we might end up with differences. But maybe not in the next couple of moths. Then fixing this in wikidata is probably easiest.

[BobBorges]

They need to be edited on wikidata:

• [x] Q116687501,"Gärde, Malcolm"
• [ ] Q117011372,"Falla, Ernst"
• [ ] Q117039047,"Gärestad,Hans Alfred Petersson"
• [ ] Q117280842,"Mora-Noret, Nils J, 5:79"
• [ ] Q117288109,"Stockholm, Per Oskar Samuelson"
• [ ] Q117288989,"Göteborg, Gustav Harald Svensson"
• [ ] Q15956417,"Stockholm, Gustaf, 1:152"
• [ ] Q3373681,"Äppelviken, Axel"
• [x] Q459226,"Stockholm, Anita I, 1:91"
• [ ] Q4730705,"Alversjö, Allan F A, 2:160"
• [ ] Q4795536,"Lekåsa, J Aron, 4:321"
• [ ] Q4955783,"Sundbyberg, Margo"
• [ ] Q5712545,"Stockholm,"
• [ ] Q5715803,"Myckelgård, Gustaf"
• [ ] Q5721610,"Stockholm, Knut G"
• [ ] Q5723194,"Multrå, Johan, 5:219"
• [ ] Q5724038,"Jönköping, Carl B N"
• [ ] Q5747977,"Stockholm, Thorvald, 1:90"
• [ ] Q5768473,"Harads, Johan Erik"
• [ ] Q5768483,"Gränna, Johan Gustaf"
• [ ] Q5770994,"Skövde, J M Alfred"
• [ ] Q5777495,"Sjögesta senare Örebro, Anders P, 4:486"
• [ ] Q5780366,"Stockholm,"
• [ ] Q5785596,"Härnösand,"
• [ ] Q5786130,"Blomberg,"
• [ ] Q5789110,"Gårda, Gustav W"
• [ ] Q5795578,"Riseberga,"
• [ ] Q5795659,"Stjärnebo, F A Hugo, 2:73"
• [ ] Q5854947,"Visby, C Suno H"
• [ ] Q5885438,"Kalmar, J August"
• [ ] Q5928617,"Kyrkdal senare Sollefteå, E Harald, 5:235"
• [ ] Q5942265,"Ystad,"
• [ ] Q5951819,"Göteborg,"
• [ ] Q5961317,"Tjörn, Axel V, 4:118"
• [ ] Q6001576,"Stockholm, Carl Göran D"
• [ ] Q6011317,"Stävie, Nils"
• [ ] Q6026693,"Rögle,"
• [ ] Q6026862,"Kullenbergstorp, Gillis O T C , 3:252"
• [ ] Q6027237,"Kvarnbrodda, Jöns"
• [ ] Q6031148,"Anderstorp, C E Holge, 2:174"
• [ ] Q6044908,"Hasselstad, August, 3:71"
• [ ] Q6045550,"Ugglekull, Peter"
• [ ] Q6062302,"Övedskloster, Otto A P, 3:265"
• [ ] Q6139775,"Öckerö,"
• [ ] Q6157386,"Hammerdal, Johan"
• [ ] Q6161169,"Hofors, H Hjalmar, 5:167"
• [ ] Q6195438,"Växjö, S A Gustaf, 2:238"
• [ ] Q6199292,"Stockholm, David C, 1:177"
• [ ] Q6199894,"Örebro, G Ruben"
• [ ] Q6255608,"Stångby, Jöns, 3:293"
• [ ] Q6298643,"Gäre, Carl"

[MansMeg]

Ping @salgo60 . Is this something you could take a pass on?

[salgo60]

• [x] Q116687501,"Gärde, Malcolm"
• [x] Q117011372,"Falla, Ernst"
• [x] Q117039047,"Gärestad,Hans Alfred Petersson"
• [x] Q117280842,"Mora-Noret, Nils J, 5:79"
• [x] Q117288109,"Stockholm, Per Oskar Samuelson"
• [x] Q117288989,"Göteborg, Gustav Harald Svensson"
• [x] Q15956417,"Stockholm, Gustaf, 1:152"
• [x] Q3373681,"Äppelviken, Axel"
• [x] Q459226,"Stockholm, Anita I, 1:91"
• [x] Q4730705,"Alversjö, Allan F A, 2:160"
• [x] Q4795536,"Lekåsa, J Aron, 4:321"
• [x] Q4955783,"Sundbyberg, Margo"
• [x] Q5712545,"Stockholm,"
• [x] Q5715803,"Myckelgård, Gustaf"
• [x] Q5721610,"Stockholm, Knut G"
• [x] Q5723194,"Multrå, Johan, 5:219"
• [x] Q5724038,"Jönköping, Carl B N"
• [x] Q5747977,"Stockholm, Thorvald, 1:90"
• [x] Q5768473,"Harads, Johan Erik"
• [x] Q5768483,"Gränna, Johan Gustaf"
• [x] Q5770994,"Skövde, J M Alfred"
• [x] Q5777495,"Sjögesta senare Örebro, Anders P, 4:486"
• [x] Q5780366,"Stockholm,"
• [x] Q5785596,"Härnösand,"
• [x] Q5786130,"Blomberg,"
• [x] Q5789110,"Gårda, Gustav W"
• [x] Q5795578,"Riseberga,"
• [x] Q5795659,"Stjärnebo, F A Hugo, 2:73"
• [x] Q5854947,"Visby, C Suno H"
• [x] Q5885438,"Kalmar, J August"
• [x] Q5928617,"Kyrkdal senare Sollefteå, E Harald, 5:235"
• [x] Q5942265,"Ystad,"
• [x] Q5951819,"Göteborg,"
• [x] Q5961317,"Tjörn, Axel V, 4:118"
• [x] Q6001576,"Stockholm, Carl Göran D"
• [x] Q6011317,"Stävie, Nils"
• [x] Q6026693,"Rögle,"
• [x] Q6026862,"Kullenbergstorp, Gillis O T C , 3:252"
• [x] Q6027237,"Kvarnbrodda, Jöns"
• [x] Q6031148,"Anderstorp, C E Holge, 2:174"
• [x] Q6044908,"Hasselstad, August, 3:71"
• [x] Q6045550,"Ugglekull, Peter"
• [x] Q6062302,"Övedskloster, Otto A P, 3:265"
• [x] Q6139775,"Öckerö,"
• [x] Q6157386,"Hammerdal, Johan"
• [x] Q6161169,"Hofors, H Hjalmar, 5:167"
• [x] Q6195438,"Växjö, S A Gustaf, 2:238"
• [x] Q6199292,"Stockholm, David C, 1:177"
• [x] Q6199894,"Örebro, G Ruben"
• [x] Q6255608,"Stångby, Jöns, 3:293"
• [x] Q6298643,"Gäre, Carl"

[salgo60]

@MansMeg what problem did you find with Q117288109

• Q117288109#P2561

---

• My changelog Special:Contributions/Salgo60

[MansMeg]

I think that one is actually a problem with us grabbing the data. Here we use the alias that is incorrect. @BobBorges , right?

[salgo60]

All checked not all changed as I didnt see a problem...

• My changelog Special:Contributions/Salgo60

• over and out now I will go and sleep in my hammock for some days ;-)

---

Off topic I mentioned your project today as a pattern how other organizations should work with its metadata

[BobBorges]

Should be fixed now. If we find this as an issue again, we could write a unit test. Caused by trailing commas (removed on wikidata) and alias/i-ort in the format surname-iort, firstname. Fixed on wikidata.