search

welfare-state-analytics / riksdagen-corpus

Swedish parliamentary proceedings - Riksdagens protokoll 1867-today
Other
26 stars 5 forks source link

Missing Wiki_ID for members in parliament in 1925 #244

Closed lirrek closed 1 year ago

lirrek commented 1 year ago

Hi everyone! I have found three MPs that do not have a wiki_id. They are the following (reference to the "Biografibanden" in the parentheses):

  1. Ernst Göransson (spelled ”Göranson” in the roll call protocol), Alias: Göransson i Falla, Chamber: Andra kammaren (AK), Years active: 1925-1928, District: Jönköpings län. (Biografibanden, Band 2, p. 156). He appears in the first roll call protocol on the 28th of february 1925.

  2. Otto Johansson, Alias: Johansson i Väby, Chamber: Andra kammaren, Years active: 1925-1932 (21-03-1932), District: Älvsborgs södra valkrets. (Biografibanden, Band 4, p. 241) He appears in the first roll call protocol on the 28th of february 1925.

  3. Herman Smedh, Alias: Smedh i Bergarklås, Replaced Fredrik Aarnseth in AK when Fredrik died in 16th April 1925. Chamber: Andra kammaren & Första kammaren, Years active: 1925 (16-05-1925) – 1928 and FK in 1936. District: Kopparbergs län. (Biografibanden, Band 5, p. 92). He makes his first appearance in the roll call protocol on the 16th of may 1925.

Hope this information is enough and useful. More information on the MPs can be found in the cited pages in the Biografibanden.

MansMeg commented 1 year ago

Hi!

I looked them up quickly. 1 and 3 seem to be missing also in Wikidata. @salgo60 could you confirm this? I.e. I guess we need to add them to wikidata? 2 has wiki id Q116687054, @ninpnin can you check why we don't have him in the data? It seems like a bug?

salgo60 commented 1 year ago

Thanks WIP - @MansMeg @lirrek

Let me know if we should share screens and I can show you how I work... I am available until friday and will be in the Italien alps next week not caring about Swedish PM people ;-)

  1. Ernst Göransson is SPA sj9PGLAlnmUAAAAAABgbEw

    1. He was on an ambiguation page see Google search in video
    image

    image

    1. Links to the not created page
    1. I created him as WD Q117011372 see also pictures on commons image

  2. Done Otto Johansson se video

    1. YES was in WIkidata but wrong linked in sv:Wikipedia on 2 pages
      1. Västra Götalands läns södra valkrets
      2. Lista över ledamöter av Sveriges riksdags andra kammare 1929–1932

  3. Done Herman Smedh video

    1. Wikidata Q117018060
    2. Was mentioned in sv:Wikipedia
      1. Dalarnas_läns_valkrets
      2. Lista över ledamöter av Sveriges riksdags andra kammare 1925–1928
MansMeg commented 1 year ago

Thanks @salgo60 ! Do we know which people are missing or should we just add them as we find them?

Could you also add Herman Smedh? I have a vague memory that you said that you would be happy to add people that are missing and we find. Let me know if that is not correct.

salgo60 commented 1 year ago

@MansMeg call me its easier 0735152802

  1. We also have all the list in sv.Wikipedia I have thought of checking them writing a program but I trust the book much more...
  2. I guess we also can use what they have done in Riksarkivet SBL as they have classified a person as a Riksdagsman
  3. When I touch a person I also add if it in Tvåkammar Riksdagen Q110346241 article says that a father was a Swedish PM in Member of the Riksdag of the Estates Q....
MansMeg commented 1 year ago

Great! Then this should now be fixed. The second person was apparently incorrectly linked but has now been fixed.

@ninpnin Could you do a rerun toward wikidata and see that we now include these people?

salgo60 commented 1 year ago

@MansMeg cc: @miroli @Ainali @SchermanJ

How WD merge objects - the last 365 days - 33 times

image

image

how we describe conflicting opinions - based on the EU RENDER project

My guess excellent for the Academic world.... If you are interested FactGrid runs Wikibase at the Gotha research center I know him Olaf / twitter

image image

How I modell "I Riksdagen kallad"

In addition to alias I do the following --> we get a source and also can add a sequence - we lack a date when it changed...

image image

GITHUB rep that updates PM data

lirrek commented 1 year ago

Hello again!

I found one MP that has a wiki_id but is not in the "member_of_parliament.csv" data. Gustaf Johnsson, Q111804160, https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q111804160

You can also find him in the "Biografibanden", Band 2, p. 285

In the "name.csv", only his last name is prevalent. In the "alias.csv" both his alias and name are shown.

MansMeg commented 1 year ago

Great! Yes, I think this is another bug we probably should fix. My guess is that this person is lacking the role in wikidata. Hence he is included but we dont know about when he is an MP.

I set this up as a separate issue to fix:

252

salgo60 commented 1 year ago

Updated Q111804160 with position held P39

cc: @MansMeg @lirrek

MansMeg commented 1 year ago

Great! This means that this will be fixed as soon as we do a new release with updates of wikidata. So I close this issue now.