welfare-state-analytics / riksdagen-corpus

Swedish parliamentary proceedings - Riksdagens protokoll 1867-today
Other
26 stars 5 forks source link

Adding and fix quality of chamber role (kammaruppdrag) in MP database #286

Open fredrik1984 opened 1 year ago

fredrik1984 commented 1 year ago

If I have understood it correctly, the official role of MP replacer started with the new constitution in 1974. It is important to add this metadata category to the MP database. I know that many MP replacers from this period have been given this role in Wikidata (look for the category "replaces"): https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5983926. Info about replacer is found in the bio books 1971–1993/94

However, if an MP has both been a replacer and an ordinary MP I have seen several cases were these roles have been mixed up in Wikidata. This is an example: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q21795365 she was first a replacer in 1988 and then ordinary MP from 1990, which Wikidata misses.

In this dictionary, a replacer (ersättare) is called "alternate member". flersprakig-ordlista-nov2020.pdf

MansMeg commented 1 year ago

See discussion in #278 on replacement. Probably ersättare depends on the election result. When adding replacement mps we should:

Depending on the difficulty it may be reasonable to also add the type of replacement, such as:

We should also ask what type of roles that are of interest to the Riksdagens öppna data.

Although adding this information might be step 2.

salgo60 commented 1 year ago

Another never ending discussion task on Wikipedia is "Riksdagens ställföreträdande och vice statsminister" #67 that we miss in machine readable data but is a little bit related to substitutes see comment "Regeringskansliets kommunikationsenhet"

Hej Magnus, Tack för ditt mejl till Statsrådsberedningen.Vice statsminister är inte någon formell titel i konstitutionell mening. Statsministern kan ge ett statsråd benämningen vice statsminister. Statsminister Magdalena Andersson har inte gett något statsråd den benämningen. Med vänlig hälsning Alena Zakharava Regeringskansliets kommunikationsenhet

MansMeg commented 1 year ago

This issue is of importance for the voting protocols project also. Another argument to try to fix this.

MansMeg commented 1 year ago

Also see #305

fredrik1984 commented 10 months ago

also #304 and #368