Please remove ProtonMail domains

[ghost]

Hi!

Please remove ProtonMail domains from your list. Yes, they provide anonymous registration, but outlook (from Microsoft evil corp) provides anonymous registration too!

Here is a proof:

https://github.com/disposable/disposable/assets/152306456/0834a69a-5944-4262-9349-3853e1852eff

You can simply create disposable mail account on outlook. So… Why blocking Proton but not Outlook?

Here is the list of domains that should be removed:

protonmail.ch
proton.me
pm.me
simplelogin.com
silomails.com
slmails.com
simplelogin.fr
aleeas.com
slmail.me
8shield.net
dralias.com
passinbox.com
passfwd.com
passmail.com
passmail.net

[ghost]

https://github.com/wesbos/burner-email-providers/issues/422#issue-2014732132

protonmail.com forgotten

THIS SHOULD BE UNBLOCKED

protonmail.ch
protonmail.com
proton.me
pm.me
simplelogin.com
silomails.com
slmails.com
simplelogin.fr
aleeas.com
slmail.me
8shield.net
dralias.com
passinbox.com
passfwd.com
passmail.com
passmail.net

[ghost]

@emh-rowland-oconnor, @mtmail, @peq42, @alexharrington, @smeinecke, @beeyev and other contributors. Please remove this domains.

[mtmail]

THIS SHOULD BE UNBLOCKED

Only slmail.me is in the emails.txt file.

[mtmail]

This repository doesn't have a ignore list. I'm not the maintainer.

[emh-rowland-oconnor]

what's changed since #414?

• Signups still possible using other DEAs as backup emails
• Zero friction / user identity verification

[Brendan-D15]

Yahoo also provides temporary/burner emails: https://help.yahoo.com/kb/SLN28815.html

[Stetsed]

It should be noted that the Proton domains have been removed, the only remaining domain that belongs to SL/PM is currently "slmail.me", atleast that's the only one I can still see in the list.

I also think the argument that Proton is somehow worse because it tries to protect it's users privacy is kinda insane, as with this same argument you could block Skiff/Tutanota and basically every other privacy respecting e-mail service. Hell you could even push it further and into most large mail providers as very few have actual measures against registration. And both Proton and SL do have measures to prevent mass reg, as can be seen when trying to register via VPN/TOR that you either need to pay, have a backup phone/e-mail or other measures that they added recently.

Also saying that it's up to whoever implements the list to decide what they do with it is just wrong, when a project implements a list like this they don't go through it and check it they just assume "Hey.. it has stars and looks good.. block all e-mail in this list" which just makes it harder for people using privacy respecting e-mail services because you decided it should be on there and then each time it's implemented those users have to go to the service and pray to god they have support and have them unblock it.

[Tepik47]

@emh-rowland-oconnor

READ THIS CAREFULLY (and follow links)

What will you say about such websites:

1. One (link)
2. Two (link)
3. Three (link)

All three websites provides DISPOSABLE gmail addresses.

So you MUST block gmail.

Also. Apple provides DISPOSABLE solutions too.

Proof one and proof two (official manual)

So you MUST block ICloud.

Also. Outlook provides DISPOSABLE addresses. Proof. You can create and delete three ones per day.

So you MUST block Outlook.

Do you think it is end? Hell no!

Yahoo provides DISPOSABLE mails. Proof

So you MUST block Yahoo.

IT IS CRITICAL FOR UNDERSTANDING TO FOLLOW ALL OFFICIAL LINKS IN THIS POST TO GET PROOFS.

So block:

gmail.com
outlook.com
icloud.com
yahoo.com

Or unblock Proton.

[Tepik47]

@stetsed, he blocked not only Proton. Also Tutanota (see https://github.com/wesbos/burner-email-providers/issues/420), Skiff (see https://github.com/wesbos/burner-email-providers/issues/423)