whai362 / PSENet

Official Pytorch implementations of PSENet.
Apache License 2.0
1.17k stars 344 forks source link

Is resnet 50 used as backbone in ICPR MTWI 2018 Challenge 2? or other #6

Open liny23 opened 5 years ago

liny23 commented 5 years ago

in ICPR MTWI 2018 Challenge 2, your result is F = 75.2, which do you select as backbone, resnet50,resnet101 or resnet152?

whai362 commented 5 years ago

resnet 152

whai362 commented 5 years ago

the backbone is resnet 152,i think without ic17 pretrain model is also ok,because icpr has enough images.

liny23 commented 5 years ago

i use fpn as your done, but the result is bad. as far as you know, how much can FPN improve?

whai362 commented 5 years ago

you can use pspnet or other common segmentation framework. the fpn is not necessary.

whai362 commented 5 years ago

all we need is a segmentation result,kernel and the algorithm of expanding.

I mean the key idea is the kernel mechanism and expanding method,the segmentation framework is alternative.

liny23 commented 5 years ago

all we need is a segmentation result,kernel and the algorithm of expanding.

your paper said: The backbone of PSENet is implemented from FPN, F = C(P 2 , P 3 , P 4 , P 5 ) = P 2 k Up ×2 (P 3 ) k Up ×4 (P 4 ) k Up ×8 (P 5 ). i wonder whether my result with fpn is reasonable ? is FPN helpful to improve detection result?

whai362 commented 5 years ago

is FPN helpful to improve detection result?Yes, fpn is help to make accurate segmentation. But there are some details in the code. So if you are trying to build a psenet-like method easily,i think implement from other segmentation framework (e.g. pspnet) is also ok. But pspnet need more gpu memory,and the speed is slower.

zzdang commented 5 years ago

请问ICPR MTWI 2018 这个模型可以分享吗

hetianduan commented 4 years ago

请问ICPR MTWI 2018 这个模型可以分享吗

你好 2018模型您有了吗