whole-tale / reproducibility-components

Models and queries of scientific reproducibility
MIT License
1 stars 2 forks source link

Find references for definitions of transparent/transparency #1

Closed tmcphillips closed 5 years ago

tmcphillips commented 5 years ago

Reviewer comment R2.09:

Is there a good citation for the definition of "transparent"? It may be helpful in the definition in Section 3.

The paper currently does include the definition recommended by FASEB. The NAS report uses the term, but does not define the term directly. We should find and cite a number of additional papers/recommendations that explicitly define transparency.

tmcphillips commented 5 years ago

Added this footnote to section 2:

The term transparency is used to refer to this aspect of reproducibility in both the FASEB recommendations [10] and the NAS report [7] discussed in Section 4.