Closed userofgithub1 closed 6 years ago
Perhaps you put a link target where you should have had a score or something.
This software has not been maintained for years and is merely archived here
https://github.com/wikilinks/neleval replaced it
Thank you for your reply and for pointing out that other library, I thought it was only for TAC but it looks like it can evaluate Conll.
Thank you again,
@jnothman One more question about neleval. Do we have to use a wikipedia dump of 2011, the same year or the annotation of CONLL or is neleval evaluation is mapped to another version of wikipedia?
Also, could you please give an example of how to run neleval evaluation for conll dataset. All the examples run of TAC dataset golden spans.
Thank you,
There's no constraint on which version of Wikipedia, as long as the IDs are consistent. For the CoNLL-AIDA dataset, your performance will be best if you map your output to be consistent with the gold standard, obviously.
Sorry I can't construct an example now, but:
$ ./nel prepare-conll-coref -h
usage: neleval prepare-conll-coref [-h] [--with-kb] [--cross-doc] [system]
Import format from CoNLL coreference for evaluation
positional arguments:
system
optional arguments:
-h, --help show this help message and exit
--with-kb By default all cluster labels are treated as NILs. This flag
treats all as KB IDs unless prefixed by "NIL"
--cross-doc By default, label space is independent per document. This flag
assumes global label space.
This doesn't seem to include mapping and, in fact, I'm not sure whether we have that in the current version..
Thank you so much.
@jnothman I have some more questions about neleval if you allow me since most of its documentation is about TAC.
-Will prepare-conll-coref
evaluate a systems output with CoNLL-AIDA gold standards?? or is it a specific measure that is different from the TAC measures?
-What is meant by the argument[system]
is it the output of the systems under evaluation?
-Also, does --with-kb
measure micro precision? or does it produce all the evaluation measures?
Sorry if my questions seem really shallow and show lack of knwoledge, I'm new to this topic and still trying my best to learn.
Thank you,
Yes, system is a system output. It is in brackets only because it can be alternatively supplied on standard input rather than a command line argument.
with-kb will allow all evaluation measures. prepare-conll-coref does not perform the evaluation
@jnothman Thank you, this is truly appreciated.
Hi @userofgithub1, I'm trying to get some better documentation up at https://neleval.readthedocs.io/
On 27 May 2018 at 22:32, userofgithub1 notifications@github.com wrote:
@jnothman https://github.com/jnothman Thank you, this is truly appreciated.
— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/wikilinks/conll03_nel_eval/issues/60#issuecomment-392327752, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAEz65CYFkySJcVxDnkGSfz1xs8k9W8jks5t2pzjgaJpZM4T4fwF .
Hey @jnothman, Thank you, these are useful docs. However, most examples are on TAC prepare and evaluate. Regarding CoNLL-AIDA, I have the output of testb from NEL framework in neleval format (7 columns) which looks like this:
1164testb RUGBY 1474 1491 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrea_Castellani 1.0 PERSON
And I have the entire dataset file AIDA-YAGO2-dataset.tsv
, which looks like this:
-DOCSTART- (1251testb Russia)
Russia B Russia Russia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russia /m/06bnz
warns
Norilsk B Norilsk --NME--
,
not
expected
to
liquidate
it
.
So, when the following command is executed on the benchmark dataset no file is generated for later use with neleval 'evaluate' command:
$ neleval prepare-conll-coref\
/path/to/AIDA-YAGO2-dataset.tsv\ #dataset file
How to convert CoNLL-AIDA gold standard to evaluation format?
Thank you so much,
Sorry that I misunderstood the issue here... CoNLL03+AIDA != CoNLL 2011-2
Hey, When I perform the prepare step, I get this error:
How can I resolve this error?
Any guidance will be much appreciated. Many thanks,